I love the season of Advent. In it, we set our eyes on Messiah's arrival. We prepare to receive the newborn in a lowly manger at Bethlehem, to celebrate the coming of Messiah Jesus into the world. We receive again the message of God’s kingdom come. And we look forward to Jesus’ coming again and the establishment of God’s new creation. In Advent, we wait, we wait for a miracle...
Waiting for a Miracle
In the darkness
She comes.
In the quiet cold
He approaches.
Spirit speaks, mouths muted.
Waiting for a miracle.
Child unborn;
Young mother, in the darkness waits.
Promise yet fulfilled;
Hope.
In mass of humanity
Angel speaks;
Promise.
Yet, injustice reigns.
In the valley of death’s shadow
Humanity sits.
Death’s dark shadow lingers.
Sin crouches at the door.
Good news for the poor?
Captives released?
The oppressed liberated?
Where?
How long will you hide yourself, O Lord?
Will you hide yourself forever?
Remember your servants,
Those who suffer for your name’s sake.
Holy Spirit broods
Over this world so broken.
Waiting, longing, listening.
For those who will say,
Yes, Lord!
I will follow,
I will listen,
I will wait,
For You.
In the darkness of this world,
So broken,
Still groaning,
Longing for another Day.
I will follow,
I will listen,
I will wait,
For Messiah.
God’s promise fulfilled.
Love, come down.
Mystery, revealed in the darkness.
Behold, the Man!
Who has come, who will come, who always comes.
Advent, coming.
In the darkness, hope and joy revealed;
Steadfast love and faithfulness meet;
Righteousness and peace kiss.
Messiah comes,
Bringing light and life;
Shalom and freedom.
Will we receive him, again?
December 19, 2012
January 29, 2012
Kierkegaard on Anxiety
Soren Kierkegaard on "the concept of anxiety":
One sticks one’s finger into the soil to tell by the smell in what land one is: I stick my finger in existence — it smells of nothing. Where am I? Who am I? How came I here? What is this thing called the world? What does this world mean? Who is it that has lured me into the world? Why was I not consulted, why not made acquainted with its manners and customs instead of throwing me into the ranks, as if I had been bought by a kidnapper, a dealer in souls? How did I obtain an interest in this big enterprise they call reality? Why should I have an interest in it? Is it not a voluntary concern? And if I am to be compelled to take part in it, where is the director? I should like to make a remark to him. Is there no director? Whither shall I turn with my complaint?
One sticks one’s finger into the soil to tell by the smell in what land one is: I stick my finger in existence — it smells of nothing. Where am I? Who am I? How came I here? What is this thing called the world? What does this world mean? Who is it that has lured me into the world? Why was I not consulted, why not made acquainted with its manners and customs instead of throwing me into the ranks, as if I had been bought by a kidnapper, a dealer in souls? How did I obtain an interest in this big enterprise they call reality? Why should I have an interest in it? Is it not a voluntary concern? And if I am to be compelled to take part in it, where is the director? I should like to make a remark to him. Is there no director? Whither shall I turn with my complaint?
December 17, 2011
Advent Love
But the love of our Lord God remains faithful forever and ever and ever to those who seek God. The Lord God's steadfast, righteous mercy holds good for the children's children of those who keep God's covenanting bond, who keep on remembering God's Words by doing them.
- Psalm 103.17-18
Advent is a time to hear to herald a message of good news for the world - a message of hope, joy, peace, and LOVE. During the Advent and Christmas season, we remember and experience afresh the love of God, come in human flesh in the person of King Jesus the Messiah.
In the tender compassion of our God
the dawn from on high shall break upon us,
to shine on those who dwell in darkness
and the shadow of death,
and to guide our feet into the way of peace. (Luke 1.79)
God is the object of love. God is love and love comes from God. True love is defined in God’s terms. Humans do not set the standards. Godly love is unconditional, self-sacrificing, active, and thoughtful. And this God-love is most clearly revealed in Jesus the Messiah - in his life, death, resurrection, and exultation.
“In this the love of God was made known among us, that God sent his only Son into the world so that we might live through him. In this is love, not that we have loved God but that he loved us and sent his Son to be the atoning sacrifice for our sins. Beloved, if God so loved us, we also ought to love one another” (1 John 4.9-11).
In Jesus, God shows his extravagant love by gathering his rebellious people, by healing the sick and unclean, by accepting the unaccepted, by entering into fellowship with sinners. And God calls us to do the same!
As we dwell in the Holy Spirit of Christ, we are God’s healers. As we live into Jesus’ story, we increasingly love as Christ loves. We follow Jesus in loving God with our whole person. Love for God is the great and basic demand made by Jesus. Jesus calls us to love God first, and our neighbor second. And the demand here is that we submit to Christ’s lordship, basing our life on God, clinging to God with bold faith, and walking in the strength of God’s Spirit. This is our joy!
With this in mind, we return again to our Advent them of darkness and light. As we walk in the Light of God's love, we must always be prepared to face the darkness within us and outside of us. As we follow Jesus, we must be prepared to suffer for the sake of the gospel, to make huge sacrifices in our lives, and even to face persecution.
If we choose to follow Jesus and to love like him, it will cost us our lives (possibly unto death, as it has been for many Christian martyrs down through the ages).
This is not to say we should go looking for trouble. No. It is to say that when we follow Christ faithfully, persecution will come and find us! Spiritual warfare is an assumed fact in the life of the New Testament church, and it should be for us as well. If, that is, we are living a Spirit-filled life. Those with ears, let them hear what the Spirit is saying...
- Psalm 103.17-18
Advent is a time to hear to herald a message of good news for the world - a message of hope, joy, peace, and LOVE. During the Advent and Christmas season, we remember and experience afresh the love of God, come in human flesh in the person of King Jesus the Messiah.
In the tender compassion of our God
the dawn from on high shall break upon us,
to shine on those who dwell in darkness
and the shadow of death,
and to guide our feet into the way of peace. (Luke 1.79)
God is the object of love. God is love and love comes from God. True love is defined in God’s terms. Humans do not set the standards. Godly love is unconditional, self-sacrificing, active, and thoughtful. And this God-love is most clearly revealed in Jesus the Messiah - in his life, death, resurrection, and exultation.
“In this the love of God was made known among us, that God sent his only Son into the world so that we might live through him. In this is love, not that we have loved God but that he loved us and sent his Son to be the atoning sacrifice for our sins. Beloved, if God so loved us, we also ought to love one another” (1 John 4.9-11).
In Jesus, God shows his extravagant love by gathering his rebellious people, by healing the sick and unclean, by accepting the unaccepted, by entering into fellowship with sinners. And God calls us to do the same!
As we dwell in the Holy Spirit of Christ, we are God’s healers. As we live into Jesus’ story, we increasingly love as Christ loves. We follow Jesus in loving God with our whole person. Love for God is the great and basic demand made by Jesus. Jesus calls us to love God first, and our neighbor second. And the demand here is that we submit to Christ’s lordship, basing our life on God, clinging to God with bold faith, and walking in the strength of God’s Spirit. This is our joy!
With this in mind, we return again to our Advent them of darkness and light. As we walk in the Light of God's love, we must always be prepared to face the darkness within us and outside of us. As we follow Jesus, we must be prepared to suffer for the sake of the gospel, to make huge sacrifices in our lives, and even to face persecution.
If we choose to follow Jesus and to love like him, it will cost us our lives (possibly unto death, as it has been for many Christian martyrs down through the ages).
This is not to say we should go looking for trouble. No. It is to say that when we follow Christ faithfully, persecution will come and find us! Spiritual warfare is an assumed fact in the life of the New Testament church, and it should be for us as well. If, that is, we are living a Spirit-filled life. Those with ears, let them hear what the Spirit is saying...
Advent Peace: Part II
O yes, shun evil and do what is good; seek shalom - pursue the fullness of peace!
Present with those who do what is just are the watchful eyes of Yahweh, God's ears attend to their cries.
Remembrance of those who do what is unjust: the face of the Lord God is turned to wipe it off from the face of the earth!
- Psalm 34.14-16
Throughout human history the mechanisms of war and human violence have been put forward as a means to an end. And in modern times, media outlets send out daily reminders of humanity’s willingness to fight and kill. We’re told that we must be willing to go to war if we want to see peace. It’s said that armed conflict is inevitable if we want to see true development work happen around the world.
Really? Is it true that we must have military solutions to the problems we face in the world?
The difficulty with this view is that war and violence often play a false role in history. They parade as the true way to liberate people from oppression and to bring a sense of security. But the hard truth to which the history of civilization attests is that violence begets the very thing it seeks to destroy. Instead of diminishing evil, violence multiplies evil.
In the words of Martin Luther King Jr., “hate multiplies hate, violence multiplies violence, and toughness multiplies toughness in a descending spiral of destruction.”
In contrast, God’s vision for peace centers on the Way of Jesus, which is marked by humility, compassion, mercy, self-sacrifice, non-violence, and peace.
God is love. And Jesus, God's only begotten Son, is the Prince of Peace. Peace (wholeness, well being, flourishing, the way of non-violence) is the divine gift offered to all people. For those who embrace God's peace, God promises to bless and keep them. God covenants to put wreaths of long-range promises and gentle love around the necks of his righteous people. No matter what our present circumstances, God always vindicates those who love and obey him. God is the protector of the poor, the defender of the defenseless, and the one who justifies those who are faithful to him.
But there will be no mercy for those who choose the way of exploitation, rebellion, and injustice. The mercy that ungodly people neglected to show others will not be shown to them. "The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who by their unrighteousness suppress the truth.
(Romans 1.18).
God is just. Speaking of the Messiah, the prophet Isaiah says, "He shall not judge by what his eyes see, or decide disputes by what his ears hear, but with righteousness he shall judge the poor, and decide with equity for the meek of the earth; and he shall strike the earth with the rod of his mouth, and with the breath of his lips she shall kill the wicked. Righteousness shall be the belt of his waist, and faithfulness the belt of his loins" (Isaiah 11.3-5).
Thankfully, God is the Just Judge, who has dealt with sin in the body of Jesus and has won the victory over the grave through Jesus resurrection from the dead. Thus, God calls his people to follow the way of love, mercy, and peace.
But the implementation of God's love and peace involves much more than the end of armed conflict. God’s shalom centers on the redemptive acts of Jesus Christ and the redeeming work of the Holy Spirit. Shalom is the total restoration of life to what God intended it to be. Thus, true peace involves the human acts of making amends, peacemaking, restoration, and living in harmony. Shalom is a movement toward fullness and completeness and encapsulates a vision of wholeness for the individual, within societal relations, and for the whole of creation.
Consider the prophet Isaiah's words about the renewal of the earth...
God shall judge between the nations,
and shall decide disputes for many peoples;
and they shall beat their swords into plowshares,
and their spears into pruning hooks;
nation shall not lift up sword against nation,
neither shall they learn war anymore. (Isaiah 2.4)
The wolf shall dwell with the lamb,
and the leopard shall lie down with the young goat,
and the calf and the lion and the fattened calf together;
and a little child shall lead them.
The cow and the bear shall graze;
their young shall lie down together;
and the lion shall eat straw like the ox.
The nursing child shall play over the hole of the cobra,
and the weaned child shall put his hand on the adder's den.
They shall not hurt or destroy
in all my holy mountain;
for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD
as the waters cover the sea. (Isaiah 11.6-9)
Because our Creator God is the worker of shalom, we, his image bearing people, have peacemaking as our holy obligation. As those who have been recreated into the image and likeness of Jesus, it is our responsibility to “make every effort to live in peace with everyone and to be holy” (Heb 12.14). Jesus says the peacemakers are blessed and they shall be called children of God (Matt 5.9). And Peace is a fruit of the Holy Spirit (Gal 5.22).
In the power of the Holy Spirit, God summons all believers to follow Jesus as we choose love over power, the cross over control, peace over revolt. The vocation of every Christian is to be a peacemaker.
In the words of Henri Nouwen, “Nobody can be a Christian without being a peacemaker...What we are called to is a life of peacemaking in which all that we do, say, think, or dream is part of our concern to bring peace to our world. Just as Jesus’ command to love one another cannot be seen as a part-time obligation, but requires our total investment and dedication, so too Jesus’ call to peacemaking is unconditional, unlimited, and uncompromising” (Peacework, 16-17).
Present with those who do what is just are the watchful eyes of Yahweh, God's ears attend to their cries.
Remembrance of those who do what is unjust: the face of the Lord God is turned to wipe it off from the face of the earth!
- Psalm 34.14-16
Throughout human history the mechanisms of war and human violence have been put forward as a means to an end. And in modern times, media outlets send out daily reminders of humanity’s willingness to fight and kill. We’re told that we must be willing to go to war if we want to see peace. It’s said that armed conflict is inevitable if we want to see true development work happen around the world.
Really? Is it true that we must have military solutions to the problems we face in the world?
The difficulty with this view is that war and violence often play a false role in history. They parade as the true way to liberate people from oppression and to bring a sense of security. But the hard truth to which the history of civilization attests is that violence begets the very thing it seeks to destroy. Instead of diminishing evil, violence multiplies evil.
In the words of Martin Luther King Jr., “hate multiplies hate, violence multiplies violence, and toughness multiplies toughness in a descending spiral of destruction.”
In contrast, God’s vision for peace centers on the Way of Jesus, which is marked by humility, compassion, mercy, self-sacrifice, non-violence, and peace.
God is love. And Jesus, God's only begotten Son, is the Prince of Peace. Peace (wholeness, well being, flourishing, the way of non-violence) is the divine gift offered to all people. For those who embrace God's peace, God promises to bless and keep them. God covenants to put wreaths of long-range promises and gentle love around the necks of his righteous people. No matter what our present circumstances, God always vindicates those who love and obey him. God is the protector of the poor, the defender of the defenseless, and the one who justifies those who are faithful to him.
But there will be no mercy for those who choose the way of exploitation, rebellion, and injustice. The mercy that ungodly people neglected to show others will not be shown to them. "The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who by their unrighteousness suppress the truth.
(Romans 1.18).
God is just. Speaking of the Messiah, the prophet Isaiah says, "He shall not judge by what his eyes see, or decide disputes by what his ears hear, but with righteousness he shall judge the poor, and decide with equity for the meek of the earth; and he shall strike the earth with the rod of his mouth, and with the breath of his lips she shall kill the wicked. Righteousness shall be the belt of his waist, and faithfulness the belt of his loins" (Isaiah 11.3-5).
Thankfully, God is the Just Judge, who has dealt with sin in the body of Jesus and has won the victory over the grave through Jesus resurrection from the dead. Thus, God calls his people to follow the way of love, mercy, and peace.
But the implementation of God's love and peace involves much more than the end of armed conflict. God’s shalom centers on the redemptive acts of Jesus Christ and the redeeming work of the Holy Spirit. Shalom is the total restoration of life to what God intended it to be. Thus, true peace involves the human acts of making amends, peacemaking, restoration, and living in harmony. Shalom is a movement toward fullness and completeness and encapsulates a vision of wholeness for the individual, within societal relations, and for the whole of creation.
Consider the prophet Isaiah's words about the renewal of the earth...
God shall judge between the nations,
and shall decide disputes for many peoples;
and they shall beat their swords into plowshares,
and their spears into pruning hooks;
nation shall not lift up sword against nation,
neither shall they learn war anymore. (Isaiah 2.4)
The wolf shall dwell with the lamb,
and the leopard shall lie down with the young goat,
and the calf and the lion and the fattened calf together;
and a little child shall lead them.
The cow and the bear shall graze;
their young shall lie down together;
and the lion shall eat straw like the ox.
The nursing child shall play over the hole of the cobra,
and the weaned child shall put his hand on the adder's den.
They shall not hurt or destroy
in all my holy mountain;
for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD
as the waters cover the sea. (Isaiah 11.6-9)
Because our Creator God is the worker of shalom, we, his image bearing people, have peacemaking as our holy obligation. As those who have been recreated into the image and likeness of Jesus, it is our responsibility to “make every effort to live in peace with everyone and to be holy” (Heb 12.14). Jesus says the peacemakers are blessed and they shall be called children of God (Matt 5.9). And Peace is a fruit of the Holy Spirit (Gal 5.22).
In the power of the Holy Spirit, God summons all believers to follow Jesus as we choose love over power, the cross over control, peace over revolt. The vocation of every Christian is to be a peacemaker.
In the words of Henri Nouwen, “Nobody can be a Christian without being a peacemaker...What we are called to is a life of peacemaking in which all that we do, say, think, or dream is part of our concern to bring peace to our world. Just as Jesus’ command to love one another cannot be seen as a part-time obligation, but requires our total investment and dedication, so too Jesus’ call to peacemaking is unconditional, unlimited, and uncompromising” (Peacework, 16-17).
December 12, 2011
Advent Peace: Part I
The Light shines in the darkness and the darkness did not overpower it.
- John 1.5
Advent is a dark time. As we journey through it, we have the opportunity to face the darkness within us and outside of us. And we face it in hope. In hope of the glory of God, now revealed in the face of Jesus - the Light of the world. We face the darkness of our present experiences in the light of God's promise of a New Day, a day of justice and peace.
And yet...
The reality is, we live in an age of violence and war. We cannot hide from this reality. We live in a world where powerful policy and monetary relationships between legislators, national armed forces, and the industrial sector form a sort-of 'iron triangle' that forcefully oppresses and enslaves people around the world. This "military-industrial complex" (MIC) is an all pervasive reality in modern western civilization. The MIC has been defined as "an informal and changing coalition of groups with vested psychological, moral, and material interests in the continuous development and maintenance of high levels of weaponry, in preservation of colonial markets and in military-strategic conceptions of internal affairs" (Carroll W. Pursell, The military-industrial complex, Harper & Row Publishers, New York, 1972).
Please note, when I speak of the MIC, I am not simply throwing stones at the glass house of America. The highly profitable business of war-waging has been conducted with impunity by Canadian Liberal and Conservative governments for decades. About three-quarters of Canada’s military exports flow to the U.S. to help arm the iron fist of the American military.
Why do I say all of this? Because the net result of our cultures of violence result in untold devastation within the human and natural world.
Take, for example, the war in Iraq (which has, for a long time now, been conveniently pushed out of the imagination of many people in the western world!). There have been two scientifically rigorous cluster surveys conducted since the US-led invasion in March 2003. "The first, published in the prestigious British medical journal The Lancet, estimated that 100,000 excess Iraqi deaths had resulted from the invasion as of September 2004. The second survey, also published in The Lancet, updated that estimate through July 2006. Due to an escalating mortality rate, the researchers estimated that over 650,000 Iraqis had died who would not have died had the death rate remained at pre-invasion levels. Roughly 601,000 of those excess deaths were due to violence...As of January 2008, a poll from the British polling firm Opinion Research Business contributed to our understanding of the Iraqi death toll, confirming the likelihood that over a million have died with an estimate of 1.2 million deaths." (http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/deathcount/explanation)
Almost 9 years of war in Iraq; an estimated $1.2 trillion of American money spent on the war machine; billions of dollars in profits because of Canadian military exports; untold damage done to the natural environment; and an estimated one million Iraqi people (mostly civilians!) are dead. Approximately one million Iraqi human beings are dead because of an unjust war. This death toll most likely eclipses the number of deaths in the Rwandan genocide.
Yet, our so-called North American mainstream media has not cover the story for years. No connections are made in the mainstream media. We hear no substantive discussion or debate about this on the evening news in Canada or the US. Little to no public discourse. This is entirely shameful. Devilish. From the pit of hell. And we are all to blame! That's right, it's the responsibility of the citizenry to gather, discuss, apply pressure on our leaders. It is our responsibility to act and demand action.
Advent.
And so, we continue to journey through the season of Advent. A dark time. Literally, the darkest time of the year. And only when we take the time and effort to face the darkness within us and outside of us, are we graced with a Godly perspective on how the Light shines in the darkness, bringing hope and peace to the world.
Shalom. Peace.
God was pleased to have all his fullness dwell in the Messiah, and through him to reconcile everything to himself by making peace through the blood of his cross - whether things on earth or things in heaven. Once you were alienated and hostile in your minds because of your evil actions. But now he has reconciled you by his physical body through his death, to present you holy, faultless, and blameless before him - if indeed you remain grounded and steadfast in the faith and are not shifted away from the hope of the gospel that you heard.
- Colossians 1.19-23
God’s purposes for the world’s redemption are fulfilled in the Messiah Jesus. By his coming in the flesh and the blood he shed on the cross, all of creation has been reconciled to God. Peace has been established in creation.
In Christ, God offers shalom to a world gone mad.
Creation is God and Christ’s good work. Nothing can change that. Not even the evils and idolatry of the military-industrial complex. The world, though spoiled by sin, still belongs to God. God has a good plan for his world and it will be accomplished. Christ’s redemption is the way the Lord of the cosmos has come to claim his rightful possession and to establish peace in it.
When we encounter the story of the Story of Jesus, we discover that in a world where humans try to establish peace by making war, God sends his Son to live a peaceable life, to die by the violence of the cross and under the weight of sin, and to rise in newness of life.
God has triumphed over the power of evil and reconciled his sin-spoiled creation through the violence of the cross. This is the deep paradox of the Christian faith.
Through the blood of Jesus’ cross, God exhausts the force of evil, God shares the suffering of humanity, God gives us life, and God establishes peace in the world.
“Peace I leave with you; my peace I give to you,” says Jesus (John 14.27). Peace is the divine gift offered to all people.
That's enough for now. More later...
- John 1.5
Advent is a dark time. As we journey through it, we have the opportunity to face the darkness within us and outside of us. And we face it in hope. In hope of the glory of God, now revealed in the face of Jesus - the Light of the world. We face the darkness of our present experiences in the light of God's promise of a New Day, a day of justice and peace.
And yet...
The reality is, we live in an age of violence and war. We cannot hide from this reality. We live in a world where powerful policy and monetary relationships between legislators, national armed forces, and the industrial sector form a sort-of 'iron triangle' that forcefully oppresses and enslaves people around the world. This "military-industrial complex" (MIC) is an all pervasive reality in modern western civilization. The MIC has been defined as "an informal and changing coalition of groups with vested psychological, moral, and material interests in the continuous development and maintenance of high levels of weaponry, in preservation of colonial markets and in military-strategic conceptions of internal affairs" (Carroll W. Pursell, The military-industrial complex, Harper & Row Publishers, New York, 1972).
Please note, when I speak of the MIC, I am not simply throwing stones at the glass house of America. The highly profitable business of war-waging has been conducted with impunity by Canadian Liberal and Conservative governments for decades. About three-quarters of Canada’s military exports flow to the U.S. to help arm the iron fist of the American military.
Why do I say all of this? Because the net result of our cultures of violence result in untold devastation within the human and natural world.
Take, for example, the war in Iraq (which has, for a long time now, been conveniently pushed out of the imagination of many people in the western world!). There have been two scientifically rigorous cluster surveys conducted since the US-led invasion in March 2003. "The first, published in the prestigious British medical journal The Lancet, estimated that 100,000 excess Iraqi deaths had resulted from the invasion as of September 2004. The second survey, also published in The Lancet, updated that estimate through July 2006. Due to an escalating mortality rate, the researchers estimated that over 650,000 Iraqis had died who would not have died had the death rate remained at pre-invasion levels. Roughly 601,000 of those excess deaths were due to violence...As of January 2008, a poll from the British polling firm Opinion Research Business contributed to our understanding of the Iraqi death toll, confirming the likelihood that over a million have died with an estimate of 1.2 million deaths." (http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/deathcount/explanation)
Almost 9 years of war in Iraq; an estimated $1.2 trillion of American money spent on the war machine; billions of dollars in profits because of Canadian military exports; untold damage done to the natural environment; and an estimated one million Iraqi people (mostly civilians!) are dead. Approximately one million Iraqi human beings are dead because of an unjust war. This death toll most likely eclipses the number of deaths in the Rwandan genocide.
Yet, our so-called North American mainstream media has not cover the story for years. No connections are made in the mainstream media. We hear no substantive discussion or debate about this on the evening news in Canada or the US. Little to no public discourse. This is entirely shameful. Devilish. From the pit of hell. And we are all to blame! That's right, it's the responsibility of the citizenry to gather, discuss, apply pressure on our leaders. It is our responsibility to act and demand action.
Advent.
And so, we continue to journey through the season of Advent. A dark time. Literally, the darkest time of the year. And only when we take the time and effort to face the darkness within us and outside of us, are we graced with a Godly perspective on how the Light shines in the darkness, bringing hope and peace to the world.
Shalom. Peace.
God was pleased to have all his fullness dwell in the Messiah, and through him to reconcile everything to himself by making peace through the blood of his cross - whether things on earth or things in heaven. Once you were alienated and hostile in your minds because of your evil actions. But now he has reconciled you by his physical body through his death, to present you holy, faultless, and blameless before him - if indeed you remain grounded and steadfast in the faith and are not shifted away from the hope of the gospel that you heard.
- Colossians 1.19-23
God’s purposes for the world’s redemption are fulfilled in the Messiah Jesus. By his coming in the flesh and the blood he shed on the cross, all of creation has been reconciled to God. Peace has been established in creation.
In Christ, God offers shalom to a world gone mad.
Creation is God and Christ’s good work. Nothing can change that. Not even the evils and idolatry of the military-industrial complex. The world, though spoiled by sin, still belongs to God. God has a good plan for his world and it will be accomplished. Christ’s redemption is the way the Lord of the cosmos has come to claim his rightful possession and to establish peace in it.
When we encounter the story of the Story of Jesus, we discover that in a world where humans try to establish peace by making war, God sends his Son to live a peaceable life, to die by the violence of the cross and under the weight of sin, and to rise in newness of life.
God has triumphed over the power of evil and reconciled his sin-spoiled creation through the violence of the cross. This is the deep paradox of the Christian faith.
Through the blood of Jesus’ cross, God exhausts the force of evil, God shares the suffering of humanity, God gives us life, and God establishes peace in the world.
“Peace I leave with you; my peace I give to you,” says Jesus (John 14.27). Peace is the divine gift offered to all people.
That's enough for now. More later...
December 5, 2011
Advent 2: Joy
Rejoice in the Lord always; again I will say, rejoice! Let your gentle spirit be known to all people. The Lord is near.
- Philippians 4.4-5
We live in troubled times. We hear stories in the news about extreme poverty, the aids crisis, and the world’s ecological crisis. We live in a world of growing isolation, frantic activity, desperate violence, and terrible injustice. And yet, we often (and paradoxically) find ourselves longing for intimacy and community, and longing to experience a sense of hope and joy. This type of tension-filled longing is what the season of Advent is all about.
In Advent, God does NOT call us to bury our heads in the sand and pretend that the world is a nice old place. No. This is a time to face the darkness and to pray that God will shine forth the Light of his loving grace. Standing firm, having shod our feet with the readiness of the gospel of peace, we face the darkness and sin within us and outside of us. We embrace our new identity in Christ: "now you are light in the Lord" (Ephesians 5.8). And so, we walk as children of Light, taking no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead exposing them (Ephesians 5.11). Beautiful!
In my reflection last week I talked about Christian hope. This week I’ll talk about joy - another major theme of Advent.
Advent is a time when we joyfully celebrate the coming of the Messiah Jesus. “Cry aloud and shout for joy, O inhabitant of Zion, for great in your midst is the Holy One of Israel” (Isaiah 12.12).
Joyous celebration characterizes the infancy narratives in the Gospels. The angel of the Lord tells Zechariah that he “will have joy and gladness and many will rejoice” at the birth of John the Baptist (Luke 1.14). The angel Gabriel tells Mary that she will give birth to God’s Messiah and her response is one of joy, thanksgiving, and worship (Luke 1.46-49). The angel announces “good news of great joy…for all people” to the shepherds (Luke 2.10-11). And when the magi find the house where Mary and Jesus are staying they “rejoice exceedingly with great joy” and “fall to the ground and worship Jesus” (Matthew 2.9-11).
Although the world is full of evil and darkness, they will not win the day. In the face of evil, God reveals his saving grace in the Messiah Jesus and the Holy Spirit. And nothing short of joy and thankfulness characterizes our human experience when we encounter the living God!
Christ, the Light of God, has come into the world to dispel the darkness and to fill us with the joy and peace of the Holy Spirit. Joyful celebration is not distant admiration. Joy is an intense love for God and neighbor, made known through our acts of faithful service. The peaceable rule of God has come in Christ and it’s our responsibility to embody that rule in the strength of the Holy Spirit.
During Advent, and beyond, I pray that we will focus our attention on our call to joyfully embody God’s love in the world. In thousands of small and big ways, let us follow God in practical acts of love. And during these Advent days of waiting, let us joyfully savor every sign of God’s loving presence as we seek God’s peace in the world!
- Philippians 4.4-5
We live in troubled times. We hear stories in the news about extreme poverty, the aids crisis, and the world’s ecological crisis. We live in a world of growing isolation, frantic activity, desperate violence, and terrible injustice. And yet, we often (and paradoxically) find ourselves longing for intimacy and community, and longing to experience a sense of hope and joy. This type of tension-filled longing is what the season of Advent is all about.
In Advent, God does NOT call us to bury our heads in the sand and pretend that the world is a nice old place. No. This is a time to face the darkness and to pray that God will shine forth the Light of his loving grace. Standing firm, having shod our feet with the readiness of the gospel of peace, we face the darkness and sin within us and outside of us. We embrace our new identity in Christ: "now you are light in the Lord" (Ephesians 5.8). And so, we walk as children of Light, taking no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead exposing them (Ephesians 5.11). Beautiful!
In my reflection last week I talked about Christian hope. This week I’ll talk about joy - another major theme of Advent.
Advent is a time when we joyfully celebrate the coming of the Messiah Jesus. “Cry aloud and shout for joy, O inhabitant of Zion, for great in your midst is the Holy One of Israel” (Isaiah 12.12).
Joyous celebration characterizes the infancy narratives in the Gospels. The angel of the Lord tells Zechariah that he “will have joy and gladness and many will rejoice” at the birth of John the Baptist (Luke 1.14). The angel Gabriel tells Mary that she will give birth to God’s Messiah and her response is one of joy, thanksgiving, and worship (Luke 1.46-49). The angel announces “good news of great joy…for all people” to the shepherds (Luke 2.10-11). And when the magi find the house where Mary and Jesus are staying they “rejoice exceedingly with great joy” and “fall to the ground and worship Jesus” (Matthew 2.9-11).
Although the world is full of evil and darkness, they will not win the day. In the face of evil, God reveals his saving grace in the Messiah Jesus and the Holy Spirit. And nothing short of joy and thankfulness characterizes our human experience when we encounter the living God!
Christ, the Light of God, has come into the world to dispel the darkness and to fill us with the joy and peace of the Holy Spirit. Joyful celebration is not distant admiration. Joy is an intense love for God and neighbor, made known through our acts of faithful service. The peaceable rule of God has come in Christ and it’s our responsibility to embody that rule in the strength of the Holy Spirit.
During Advent, and beyond, I pray that we will focus our attention on our call to joyfully embody God’s love in the world. In thousands of small and big ways, let us follow God in practical acts of love. And during these Advent days of waiting, let us joyfully savor every sign of God’s loving presence as we seek God’s peace in the world!
November 29, 2011
Advent 1: Hope
Therefore having been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom also we have obtained our introduction by faith into this grace in which we now stand; and we exult in hope of the glory of God.
- Romans 5.1-2
This past Sunday was the first Sunday of Advent. Advent marks the start of the Christian year. The word Advent means “coming” or “arrival.” In this season, Christians all over the world celebrate the birth of the Messiah Jesus and look forward to Jesus’ coming again and the establishment of God’s new creation.
In this time we wait and hope for Christ’s indwelling presence through the Holy Spirit. We wait and hope for Christ’s light to break through the darkness of our world. We wait and hope for the revelation of Christ with us, Christ among us.
In the New Testament, hope is one of the defining marks of the believer. Despite the suffering that comes from living in a fallen world, we are certain that God will one day complete what he has started, both in our own lives and in the whole world. We believe that God has acted in the past, we believe that God is acting in the present, and we believe that God will act in the future. Those beliefs are at the heart of Christian hope.
In this light, we must always remember that Christian hope is something that is active, not passive. When I say that we wait and hope for Christ’s coming during the season of Advent, I don’t mean that God wants us to sit around looking bored. On the contrary! God’s Spirit is leading us to go into the world and embody the reality of his kingdom come. In all of life, we are to show people what it looks like for God’s will to be done on earth as it is in heaven. And we do this as the people of God. Not as a bunch of individual Christians. But, as one people, who are joined together in Christ, exulting in hope of the glory of God.
Hope for a renewed world, both now and to come; may this be our focus in both the meditation of our hearts and our outward action during this season of Advent.
- Romans 5.1-2
This past Sunday was the first Sunday of Advent. Advent marks the start of the Christian year. The word Advent means “coming” or “arrival.” In this season, Christians all over the world celebrate the birth of the Messiah Jesus and look forward to Jesus’ coming again and the establishment of God’s new creation.
In this time we wait and hope for Christ’s indwelling presence through the Holy Spirit. We wait and hope for Christ’s light to break through the darkness of our world. We wait and hope for the revelation of Christ with us, Christ among us.
In the New Testament, hope is one of the defining marks of the believer. Despite the suffering that comes from living in a fallen world, we are certain that God will one day complete what he has started, both in our own lives and in the whole world. We believe that God has acted in the past, we believe that God is acting in the present, and we believe that God will act in the future. Those beliefs are at the heart of Christian hope.
In this light, we must always remember that Christian hope is something that is active, not passive. When I say that we wait and hope for Christ’s coming during the season of Advent, I don’t mean that God wants us to sit around looking bored. On the contrary! God’s Spirit is leading us to go into the world and embody the reality of his kingdom come. In all of life, we are to show people what it looks like for God’s will to be done on earth as it is in heaven. And we do this as the people of God. Not as a bunch of individual Christians. But, as one people, who are joined together in Christ, exulting in hope of the glory of God.
Hope for a renewed world, both now and to come; may this be our focus in both the meditation of our hearts and our outward action during this season of Advent.
September 26, 2011
Factor #2: Pragmatism
In our day and age, the second primary factor that militates against the essential acts of Christ-centered faith, prayer, reflection, and contemplation is: pragmatism.
I continue to draw from the book The Shattered Lantern by Ronald Rolheiser. The English word “pragmatism” comes from the Greek pragma, meaning “business.” In the western mind, pragmatism is connected to concepts like: efficiency, practicality, progress, and sensibleness. It only follows from this that pragmatism is synonymous with much of western life.
As a philosophy, pragmatism is a way of life that assesses the truth of a matter in its practical efficacy or application. What is true is what works. The test for truth is directly related to whether an idea has some concrete utility or practical benefit. “Things are good if they work, and what works is good. The ideals of pragmatism lie at the very heart of the Western mind, undergird our technological society, are deeply enshrined in our educational systems, and are evident in our impatience with anything (or anybody) that is not practical, useful, and efficient” (The Shattered Lantern, 36).
From the time of childhood we are told to climb the ladder of success, gain approval, be the best, be efficient, and ultimately to dominate. And even worse, the status of being part of the so-called “elite” is the goal in much of our western culture. Too many forms of media and the example of parents and leaders reinforce this message throughout our adolescent years. All of us are deeply affected by this thoroughly pragmatic worldview.
This is hugely problematic. Ultimately it is cancer to the soul. As Jean Vanier notes, “Elitism is the sickness of us all. We all want to be on the winning team…The important thing is to become conscious of those forces in us and to work at being liberated from them and to discover that the worst enemy is inside our own hearts not outside!” A pragmatic worldview wreaks havoc on our lives and on the world. Our lives become completely out of joint when we live by the principles “what’s good is what works” and “you are only good if you work” and “you are only as good as the work you do.” When doing counts for everything and being counts for nothing, our lives become a chaotic mess. The true priorities of worship, relationships, family, and self-giving love go out the window. And as a society, we come to undervalue children and the weak, we institutionalize people with physical disabilities or mental illness, and we discard and disregard the elderly (or anyone who is an "unproductive" member of society).
In contrast, God calls us to be last. Jesus says, “The first shall be last and the last shall be first. Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are the gentle, for they shall inherit the earth. Blessed are the merciful, for they shall receive mercy. Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God.”
Our being in God must always be our primary focus and point of reflection. Who we are in Jesus Christ is paramount. Regardless of our worldly status, our identity in Christ is all that matters. In Christ we are loved, accepted, adopted as God’s children, forgiven, redeemed, renewed by God’s Spirit, and recreated as God’s new humanity. What we do (or do not do!) should flow from the truly human identity we derive from our relationship with God, through Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit.
Further, Jesus teaches us to look beyond our ego in order to address our insecurities and our fear of being devalued. In the face of our culture’s pragmatic, progress driven, and elitist mentality, Jesus says, “Climb down the ladder of success and meet me at the bottom. There you will discover the meaning of truth and goodness, which transcends your petty notions of efficiency and practicality. Realize that life is messy, and that I have come to clean you up, set you free, and set you on the right path. Acknowledge your brokenness, your poverty of spirit, your complete dependence on God for all things. Become like a child. Trust Me. Follow God. Then go, serve the poor, enjoy fellowship with the estranged, have compassion on the sick, and share people’s pain. Only then can you experience true fellowship and communion with God and neighbor. Only then will you inherit the kingdom of heaven!”
I continue to draw from the book The Shattered Lantern by Ronald Rolheiser. The English word “pragmatism” comes from the Greek pragma, meaning “business.” In the western mind, pragmatism is connected to concepts like: efficiency, practicality, progress, and sensibleness. It only follows from this that pragmatism is synonymous with much of western life.
As a philosophy, pragmatism is a way of life that assesses the truth of a matter in its practical efficacy or application. What is true is what works. The test for truth is directly related to whether an idea has some concrete utility or practical benefit. “Things are good if they work, and what works is good. The ideals of pragmatism lie at the very heart of the Western mind, undergird our technological society, are deeply enshrined in our educational systems, and are evident in our impatience with anything (or anybody) that is not practical, useful, and efficient” (The Shattered Lantern, 36).
From the time of childhood we are told to climb the ladder of success, gain approval, be the best, be efficient, and ultimately to dominate. And even worse, the status of being part of the so-called “elite” is the goal in much of our western culture. Too many forms of media and the example of parents and leaders reinforce this message throughout our adolescent years. All of us are deeply affected by this thoroughly pragmatic worldview.
This is hugely problematic. Ultimately it is cancer to the soul. As Jean Vanier notes, “Elitism is the sickness of us all. We all want to be on the winning team…The important thing is to become conscious of those forces in us and to work at being liberated from them and to discover that the worst enemy is inside our own hearts not outside!” A pragmatic worldview wreaks havoc on our lives and on the world. Our lives become completely out of joint when we live by the principles “what’s good is what works” and “you are only good if you work” and “you are only as good as the work you do.” When doing counts for everything and being counts for nothing, our lives become a chaotic mess. The true priorities of worship, relationships, family, and self-giving love go out the window. And as a society, we come to undervalue children and the weak, we institutionalize people with physical disabilities or mental illness, and we discard and disregard the elderly (or anyone who is an "unproductive" member of society).
In contrast, God calls us to be last. Jesus says, “The first shall be last and the last shall be first. Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are the gentle, for they shall inherit the earth. Blessed are the merciful, for they shall receive mercy. Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God.”
Our being in God must always be our primary focus and point of reflection. Who we are in Jesus Christ is paramount. Regardless of our worldly status, our identity in Christ is all that matters. In Christ we are loved, accepted, adopted as God’s children, forgiven, redeemed, renewed by God’s Spirit, and recreated as God’s new humanity. What we do (or do not do!) should flow from the truly human identity we derive from our relationship with God, through Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit.
Further, Jesus teaches us to look beyond our ego in order to address our insecurities and our fear of being devalued. In the face of our culture’s pragmatic, progress driven, and elitist mentality, Jesus says, “Climb down the ladder of success and meet me at the bottom. There you will discover the meaning of truth and goodness, which transcends your petty notions of efficiency and practicality. Realize that life is messy, and that I have come to clean you up, set you free, and set you on the right path. Acknowledge your brokenness, your poverty of spirit, your complete dependence on God for all things. Become like a child. Trust Me. Follow God. Then go, serve the poor, enjoy fellowship with the estranged, have compassion on the sick, and share people’s pain. Only then can you experience true fellowship and communion with God and neighbor. Only then will you inherit the kingdom of heaven!”
August 12, 2011
The Roots of Our Present Crisis of Faith
Factors militating against the essential acts of Christ-centered faith, prayer, reflection, and contemplation…
Factor #1: Narcissism
To a certain extent, we are by nature narcissistic. To ourselves we are real and our reality is paramount. However, our natural tendency for self-preoccupation has trapped us in a spiral of self-absorbed destruction.
Narcissism is an obsession with self. It is self-centeredness arising from failure to distinguish self from external objects. Our society is chalked full of people who are unhealthily obsessed with self. (Note: I do not excuse myself from this critical analysis of our society!) We see this unhealthy obsession with self in our “propensity for individualism and our corresponding inability to be healthily aware of and concerned about the reality beyond our private lives (The Shattered Lantern, 28).
We have a growing incapacity to recognize the reality of others. We are turned in on ourselves, obsessed with self-help and self-development. An idolatrous commitment to self-advancement, luxury, ambition, achieving, and comfort is ripping the heart out of us and leaving us incapable to genuinely attend to the needs of others.
Further, our society is increasingly obsessed with excessive privacy. The destructive privatization of every area of life is taking over. There is nothing inherently wrong with privacy. To some degree, we all need our privacy. What is at issue is excessiveness. “When this need is unchecked, meaningful social interaction diminishes and the opportunity to escape into a world of private projects, private dreams, and private fantasies increases. Narcissism grows stronger when there is not enough meaningful social interaction to draw us out of our selves and make us aware of the reality outside us. This movement towards greater privacy is both a symptom and a cause of narcissism” (The Shattered Lantern, 33).
It is no wonder that we have difficulty believing in and seeing the reality of God in our daily experience when we have difficulty perceiving any reality beyond ourselves. To see and experience God’s Empowering Presence in ordinary life is to see beyond ourselves, toward others, toward the larger world, and ultimately toward an Infinite horizon.
Factor #1: Narcissism
To a certain extent, we are by nature narcissistic. To ourselves we are real and our reality is paramount. However, our natural tendency for self-preoccupation has trapped us in a spiral of self-absorbed destruction.
Narcissism is an obsession with self. It is self-centeredness arising from failure to distinguish self from external objects. Our society is chalked full of people who are unhealthily obsessed with self. (Note: I do not excuse myself from this critical analysis of our society!) We see this unhealthy obsession with self in our “propensity for individualism and our corresponding inability to be healthily aware of and concerned about the reality beyond our private lives (The Shattered Lantern, 28).
We have a growing incapacity to recognize the reality of others. We are turned in on ourselves, obsessed with self-help and self-development. An idolatrous commitment to self-advancement, luxury, ambition, achieving, and comfort is ripping the heart out of us and leaving us incapable to genuinely attend to the needs of others.
Further, our society is increasingly obsessed with excessive privacy. The destructive privatization of every area of life is taking over. There is nothing inherently wrong with privacy. To some degree, we all need our privacy. What is at issue is excessiveness. “When this need is unchecked, meaningful social interaction diminishes and the opportunity to escape into a world of private projects, private dreams, and private fantasies increases. Narcissism grows stronger when there is not enough meaningful social interaction to draw us out of our selves and make us aware of the reality outside us. This movement towards greater privacy is both a symptom and a cause of narcissism” (The Shattered Lantern, 33).
It is no wonder that we have difficulty believing in and seeing the reality of God in our daily experience when we have difficulty perceiving any reality beyond ourselves. To see and experience God’s Empowering Presence in ordinary life is to see beyond ourselves, toward others, toward the larger world, and ultimately toward an Infinite horizon.
August 4, 2011
The Shattered Lantern
I'm reading an interesting book called The Shattered Lantern: Rediscovering a Felt Presence of God. This is a book about our rediscovery of the ancient practices of reflection, contemplation, and purity of heart. "Rediscovery" because there is a problem in the church today: practical atheism.
In The Shattered Lantern, Ronald Rolheiser addresses the concerning issue of atheism and disbelief within the church. To get at this, he uses Nietzsche's parable of the madman as a starting point. A "madman" lights a lantern and in bright daylight rushes into a crowded marketplace shouting: "I seek God! I seek God!" But the people in the marketplace ridicule him, yelling and laughing at him. So the madman turns on them and shouts, "God is dead, I tell you, we have killed him, you and I. All of us are his murderers. But how did we do this? How could we drink up the sea? Who gave us the sponge to wipe away the entire horizon? What was the holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet owned has bled to death under our knives." Then he goes silent, smashes his lantern on the ground and says, "I have come too early. This deed is still too distant for people to see, and yet they have done this to themselves. They have killed God."
Practical atheism is not something that primarily exists outside the church. It is very much a phenomenon within the circle of "believers." In The Shattered Lantern, Rolheiser argues that we have killed God in that he is often absent from the ordinary consciousness and lives of believers, not alive enough alive or important enough. Why is this? Because there is something wrong with us. There is a fault in us, namely blindness.
Instead of experiencing God on a deep, intimate level, we often relate to God as a distant, detached creator. God is related to "as a religion, a church, a moral philosophy, a guide for private virtue, an imperative for justice, or a nostalgia for propriety...God, then, is more of a moral and intellectual principle than a person, and our commitment to this principle runs the gamut from fiery passion, by which people are willing to die for a cause, to a vague nostalgia, in which God and religion are given the same kind of status as the royal family in England" (pgs. 18-19).
Many Christians in Western culture today have an atrophied contemplative faculty, a muddied self-awareness. We are numb and blind to God's ever-presence. God is present to us, but we are not present to God. "The struggle to experience God is not so much one of God's presence or absence as it is one of the presence or absence of God in our awareness. God is always present, but we are not always present to God" (pg. 22).
Purity of heart and mind is the focal point of Christian spirituality. But our hearts and minds are often muddied by the cares of the world. Instead of being attentive to God in ordinary life, we are preoccupied with that which is carnal. For many of us, God is not compelling in our day-to-day experiences. We are restless, narcissistic, focused on self and our so-called pressing consumer "needs."
In this first decade of the 21st century, we are at the end of a long historical process that killed God (both knowingly and unknowingly). Our present crisis of a living and vibrant faith has deep roots that reach back hundreds of years into the middle ages. A seed was planted that has now come to full bloom...
In The Shattered Lantern, Ronald Rolheiser addresses the concerning issue of atheism and disbelief within the church. To get at this, he uses Nietzsche's parable of the madman as a starting point. A "madman" lights a lantern and in bright daylight rushes into a crowded marketplace shouting: "I seek God! I seek God!" But the people in the marketplace ridicule him, yelling and laughing at him. So the madman turns on them and shouts, "God is dead, I tell you, we have killed him, you and I. All of us are his murderers. But how did we do this? How could we drink up the sea? Who gave us the sponge to wipe away the entire horizon? What was the holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet owned has bled to death under our knives." Then he goes silent, smashes his lantern on the ground and says, "I have come too early. This deed is still too distant for people to see, and yet they have done this to themselves. They have killed God."
Practical atheism is not something that primarily exists outside the church. It is very much a phenomenon within the circle of "believers." In The Shattered Lantern, Rolheiser argues that we have killed God in that he is often absent from the ordinary consciousness and lives of believers, not alive enough alive or important enough. Why is this? Because there is something wrong with us. There is a fault in us, namely blindness.
Instead of experiencing God on a deep, intimate level, we often relate to God as a distant, detached creator. God is related to "as a religion, a church, a moral philosophy, a guide for private virtue, an imperative for justice, or a nostalgia for propriety...God, then, is more of a moral and intellectual principle than a person, and our commitment to this principle runs the gamut from fiery passion, by which people are willing to die for a cause, to a vague nostalgia, in which God and religion are given the same kind of status as the royal family in England" (pgs. 18-19).
Many Christians in Western culture today have an atrophied contemplative faculty, a muddied self-awareness. We are numb and blind to God's ever-presence. God is present to us, but we are not present to God. "The struggle to experience God is not so much one of God's presence or absence as it is one of the presence or absence of God in our awareness. God is always present, but we are not always present to God" (pg. 22).
Purity of heart and mind is the focal point of Christian spirituality. But our hearts and minds are often muddied by the cares of the world. Instead of being attentive to God in ordinary life, we are preoccupied with that which is carnal. For many of us, God is not compelling in our day-to-day experiences. We are restless, narcissistic, focused on self and our so-called pressing consumer "needs."
In this first decade of the 21st century, we are at the end of a long historical process that killed God (both knowingly and unknowingly). Our present crisis of a living and vibrant faith has deep roots that reach back hundreds of years into the middle ages. A seed was planted that has now come to full bloom...
July 28, 2011
After a long break, I'm back...
After a long sabbatical from blog writing, I will be reflecting a lot for the next few weeks. I will be reflecting on things like culture, discipleship, education, peace, pacifism, war, and the disciplines of reflection/contemplation/prayer.
Here is a nice quote to get things going:
Naturally, the common people don't want war, but after all, it is the leaders of a country who determine the policy, and it is always a simple matter to drag people along whether it is a democracy, or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. THis is easy. All you have to do is to tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to dander. It works the same in every country."
Hermann Goering,
Hitler's Reich-Marshall at the Nuremberg Trials after WWII
Here is a nice quote to get things going:
Naturally, the common people don't want war, but after all, it is the leaders of a country who determine the policy, and it is always a simple matter to drag people along whether it is a democracy, or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. THis is easy. All you have to do is to tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to dander. It works the same in every country."
Hermann Goering,
Hitler's Reich-Marshall at the Nuremberg Trials after WWII
February 28, 2011
A Few Thoughts on Parables
All these things Jesus spoke to the crowds in parables.
(Matthew 13.34)
Parables. What to do with Jesus' parables? So often, Jesus offers us riddles and dark sayings to chew on. Not facts or propositional statements, but parables.
Parables – short fictional narratives, cryptic stories about planting, harvest, mustard seeds, hidden leaven, hidden treasures, and costly pearls. These stories of Jesus invite us on an imaginative quest to seek, search, and learn more about God’s kingdom, God's reign. With whit and wisdom, Jesus uses parables to announce the coming of God’s kingdom. (As a brief reminder, “The kingdom of God/heaven” is the truth and message that Yahweh, the one true God, is King. And Jesus’ announcement of the kingdom focuses on how God establishes his rule through Jesus).
Isn't it interesting that Jesus most often tells stories that conceal, when speaking of God’s kingdom. Jesus’ parables leave us asking, “What’s he talking about, what does he mean?” And this was true for Jesus’ first disciples, as well. When Jesus told stories they asked, “What’s he saying? Why does he speak this way?” And this shouldn’t surprise us, because Jesus’ parables are not aimed at conveying information.
The aim of a parable is transformation. A parable helps “shape a heart that is willing to enter an ongoing, interactive, persistent relationship of trust in the teacher. It beckons the hearer to explore new territory. It helps form a heart that is humble enough to admit it doesn’t already understand and is thirsty enough to ask questions….a parable renders its hearers not as experts, not as know-it-alls, not as scholars…but as children” (Brian McLaren, The Secret Message of Jesus, 46).
And so, parables are theology in the truest sense of the word. Parables reveal the nature, plan, and rule of God, proclaiming what’s been “hidden from the foundation of the world." This, in turn, draws us into an intimate, loving encounter with God, through which new and unexpected ways of living are revealed to us. We are transformed through the renewing of our minds and hearts.
By way of analogy, Jesus’ parables are like a house, in which we’re invited to take up residence. They urge us to look on the world through the windows of our new residence, and allow our view of the world to be re-formed by God. Jesus calls us to see the world in a new way, with a willingness to sacrifice everything for God’s kingdom. That's what the parables are all about - laying it all on the line for God and his kingdom purposes.
(Matthew 13.34)
Parables. What to do with Jesus' parables? So often, Jesus offers us riddles and dark sayings to chew on. Not facts or propositional statements, but parables.
Parables – short fictional narratives, cryptic stories about planting, harvest, mustard seeds, hidden leaven, hidden treasures, and costly pearls. These stories of Jesus invite us on an imaginative quest to seek, search, and learn more about God’s kingdom, God's reign. With whit and wisdom, Jesus uses parables to announce the coming of God’s kingdom. (As a brief reminder, “The kingdom of God/heaven” is the truth and message that Yahweh, the one true God, is King. And Jesus’ announcement of the kingdom focuses on how God establishes his rule through Jesus).
Isn't it interesting that Jesus most often tells stories that conceal, when speaking of God’s kingdom. Jesus’ parables leave us asking, “What’s he talking about, what does he mean?” And this was true for Jesus’ first disciples, as well. When Jesus told stories they asked, “What’s he saying? Why does he speak this way?” And this shouldn’t surprise us, because Jesus’ parables are not aimed at conveying information.
The aim of a parable is transformation. A parable helps “shape a heart that is willing to enter an ongoing, interactive, persistent relationship of trust in the teacher. It beckons the hearer to explore new territory. It helps form a heart that is humble enough to admit it doesn’t already understand and is thirsty enough to ask questions….a parable renders its hearers not as experts, not as know-it-alls, not as scholars…but as children” (Brian McLaren, The Secret Message of Jesus, 46).
And so, parables are theology in the truest sense of the word. Parables reveal the nature, plan, and rule of God, proclaiming what’s been “hidden from the foundation of the world." This, in turn, draws us into an intimate, loving encounter with God, through which new and unexpected ways of living are revealed to us. We are transformed through the renewing of our minds and hearts.
By way of analogy, Jesus’ parables are like a house, in which we’re invited to take up residence. They urge us to look on the world through the windows of our new residence, and allow our view of the world to be re-formed by God. Jesus calls us to see the world in a new way, with a willingness to sacrifice everything for God’s kingdom. That's what the parables are all about - laying it all on the line for God and his kingdom purposes.
January 6, 2011
A Franciscan Benediction (for the New Year)
May God bless you with discomfort
at easy answers, half-truths, and superficial relationships;
so that you may live deep within your heart.
May God bless you with anger
at injustice, oppression, and exploitation of people;
so that you may work for justice, freedom, and peace.
May God bless you with tears
to shed for those who suffer pain, rejection, hunger and war;
so that you may reach out your hand to comfort them and
to turn their pain into joy.
And may God bless you with enough foolishness
to believe that you can make a difference in the world;
so that you can do what others claim cannot be done:
to bring justice and kindness to all our children and the poor.
Amen
at easy answers, half-truths, and superficial relationships;
so that you may live deep within your heart.
May God bless you with anger
at injustice, oppression, and exploitation of people;
so that you may work for justice, freedom, and peace.
May God bless you with tears
to shed for those who suffer pain, rejection, hunger and war;
so that you may reach out your hand to comfort them and
to turn their pain into joy.
And may God bless you with enough foolishness
to believe that you can make a difference in the world;
so that you can do what others claim cannot be done:
to bring justice and kindness to all our children and the poor.
Amen
December 9, 2010
The Light of the World
"O house of Jacob, come, let us walk in the light of Yahweh."
- Isaiah 2.5
"The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world...to all who receive him, who believe in his name, he gave the right to become children of God."
- John 1.9, 12
In the Psalms and Isaiah light is a symbol of God’s presence and salvation. Psalm 27.1 says, “Yahweh is my light and my salvation; whom shall I fear? Yahweh is the stronghold of my life; of whom shall I be afraid?” And Isaiah 60.1-3 says, “Arise, shine, for your light has come and the glory of Yahweh has risen upon you. For darkness shall cover the earth and thick darkness the peoples. But Yahweh will arise upon you and his glory will appear over you.”
Indeed, the glory of Yahweh has risen upon us in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. The coming of God’s saving light is realized in the Word made flesh, the only begotten Son of God. Jesus is God’s Light, shining into the thick darkness of this world, a world tainted by sin.
But in its darkened state, “the world” has not received God’s Light. In Scripture, “the world” usually refers to humanity in rebellion against God. Humanity is prone to reject God’s truth and replace it with a lie.
It’s said Christmas is a season of love, joy, and peace. And that’s true. But there’s a flip side to that coin, a darker side. The celebration of Jesus’ coming is not a pleasant reminder that the world is a nice old place. No, Christmas is a reminder that the world is a shockingly bad place, full of darkness and deception, and in need of God’s light.
As N.T. Wright says, "The world is where wickedness flourishes unchecked, where children are murdered, where civilized countries make a lot of money by selling weapons to uncivilized ones so they can blow each other apart. Christmas is God lighting a candle; and you don’t light a candle in a room that’s already full of sunlight. You light a candle in a room that’s so murky that the candle, when lit, reveals just how bad things really are. 'The light shines in the darkness,' says St. John, 'and the darkness has not overcome it.'" (For All God’s Worth, 2).
If we want to do justice to the Christmas story as we seek to apply it today, we must put a face to the “darkness” St. John speaks of. In John’s Gospel the people who remain in “darkness” are those who rejected the truth that Jesus is Israel’s Messiah, the Savior of the world, and the Son of God. And so today, those who remain in darkness, separated from God’s saving grace, are those who reject Jesus as the Messiah, the unique Son of God, and the Lord of the cosmos.
Eric Kunze, the former main man in Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical Jesus Christ Superstar, was quoted in the Toronto Star a few years back as saying, “Whether or not you believe he [Jesus] was the Messiah doesn’t matter. He was a man who has touched millions of people for thousands of years.” In the same article, Rick Miller, who plays the title role in his production Bigger Than Jesus, says, “Knowing what we know now, how could you possibly believe that the story of Jesus is factually true? You can believe in Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny, but how can you believe that Jesus Christ is literally the Son of God, descended to earth?”
I’m sure we’ve all heard it said, “Jesus was just a good man who preached a good message about love and peace. He was nothing more than that.” But according to John’s Christmas poem, Jesus was not just a good man. He is the very Word, Light, and Son of God, come in the flesh to save fallen humanity and redeem the whole creation. Yes, Jesus came with a message of love and peace. There’s no doubting that. But his life, message, and mission involved so much more.
In the words of Blaise Pascal: “Jesus is the center of all, the object of all, whoever does not know him, knows nothing aright, either of the world or of himself.”
In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God…In him was life, and the life was the light of people…The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world...to all who receive him, who believe in his name, he gave the right to become children of God."
Those who dwell in darkness may reject the truth and beauty of these words. But that doesn’t change the reality of who Jesus is, or what he came to accomplish. We don’t live in a nice world that is getting nicer. Thick darkness covers us. We’re sinful and wretched and must be reborn of God. And there’s only one hope for that rebirth: Jesus, the Word of God and Light of the world! Jesus has come to dwell among us and bring us the salvation we need. And to all who receive Jesus in faith, God gives them the right to be called his children. That’s the message of Christmas.
- Isaiah 2.5
"The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world...to all who receive him, who believe in his name, he gave the right to become children of God."
- John 1.9, 12
In the Psalms and Isaiah light is a symbol of God’s presence and salvation. Psalm 27.1 says, “Yahweh is my light and my salvation; whom shall I fear? Yahweh is the stronghold of my life; of whom shall I be afraid?” And Isaiah 60.1-3 says, “Arise, shine, for your light has come and the glory of Yahweh has risen upon you. For darkness shall cover the earth and thick darkness the peoples. But Yahweh will arise upon you and his glory will appear over you.”
Indeed, the glory of Yahweh has risen upon us in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. The coming of God’s saving light is realized in the Word made flesh, the only begotten Son of God. Jesus is God’s Light, shining into the thick darkness of this world, a world tainted by sin.
But in its darkened state, “the world” has not received God’s Light. In Scripture, “the world” usually refers to humanity in rebellion against God. Humanity is prone to reject God’s truth and replace it with a lie.
It’s said Christmas is a season of love, joy, and peace. And that’s true. But there’s a flip side to that coin, a darker side. The celebration of Jesus’ coming is not a pleasant reminder that the world is a nice old place. No, Christmas is a reminder that the world is a shockingly bad place, full of darkness and deception, and in need of God’s light.
As N.T. Wright says, "The world is where wickedness flourishes unchecked, where children are murdered, where civilized countries make a lot of money by selling weapons to uncivilized ones so they can blow each other apart. Christmas is God lighting a candle; and you don’t light a candle in a room that’s already full of sunlight. You light a candle in a room that’s so murky that the candle, when lit, reveals just how bad things really are. 'The light shines in the darkness,' says St. John, 'and the darkness has not overcome it.'" (For All God’s Worth, 2).
If we want to do justice to the Christmas story as we seek to apply it today, we must put a face to the “darkness” St. John speaks of. In John’s Gospel the people who remain in “darkness” are those who rejected the truth that Jesus is Israel’s Messiah, the Savior of the world, and the Son of God. And so today, those who remain in darkness, separated from God’s saving grace, are those who reject Jesus as the Messiah, the unique Son of God, and the Lord of the cosmos.
Eric Kunze, the former main man in Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical Jesus Christ Superstar, was quoted in the Toronto Star a few years back as saying, “Whether or not you believe he [Jesus] was the Messiah doesn’t matter. He was a man who has touched millions of people for thousands of years.” In the same article, Rick Miller, who plays the title role in his production Bigger Than Jesus, says, “Knowing what we know now, how could you possibly believe that the story of Jesus is factually true? You can believe in Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny, but how can you believe that Jesus Christ is literally the Son of God, descended to earth?”
I’m sure we’ve all heard it said, “Jesus was just a good man who preached a good message about love and peace. He was nothing more than that.” But according to John’s Christmas poem, Jesus was not just a good man. He is the very Word, Light, and Son of God, come in the flesh to save fallen humanity and redeem the whole creation. Yes, Jesus came with a message of love and peace. There’s no doubting that. But his life, message, and mission involved so much more.
In the words of Blaise Pascal: “Jesus is the center of all, the object of all, whoever does not know him, knows nothing aright, either of the world or of himself.”
In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God…In him was life, and the life was the light of people…The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world...to all who receive him, who believe in his name, he gave the right to become children of God."
Those who dwell in darkness may reject the truth and beauty of these words. But that doesn’t change the reality of who Jesus is, or what he came to accomplish. We don’t live in a nice world that is getting nicer. Thick darkness covers us. We’re sinful and wretched and must be reborn of God. And there’s only one hope for that rebirth: Jesus, the Word of God and Light of the world! Jesus has come to dwell among us and bring us the salvation we need. And to all who receive Jesus in faith, God gives them the right to be called his children. That’s the message of Christmas.
December 1, 2010
A Word of Hope During Advent
A word from Scripture...
"Isaiah says, 'The root of Jesse will come, even he who arises to rule the Gentiles; in him will the Gentiles hope.' May the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, so that by the poser of the Holy Spirit you may abound in hope."
- Romans 15.12-13
And a word from Emily Dickinson...
Hope Is the Thing With Feathers
Emily Dickinson
Hope is the thing with feathers
That perches in the soul,
And sings the tune without the words,
And never stops at all,
And sweetest in the gale is heard;
And sore must be the storm
That could abash the little bird
That kept so many warm.
I've heard it in the chillest land,
And on the strangest sea;
Yet, never, in extremity,
It asked a crumb of me.
"Isaiah says, 'The root of Jesse will come, even he who arises to rule the Gentiles; in him will the Gentiles hope.' May the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, so that by the poser of the Holy Spirit you may abound in hope."
- Romans 15.12-13
And a word from Emily Dickinson...
Hope Is the Thing With Feathers
Emily Dickinson
Hope is the thing with feathers
That perches in the soul,
And sings the tune without the words,
And never stops at all,
And sweetest in the gale is heard;
And sore must be the storm
That could abash the little bird
That kept so many warm.
I've heard it in the chillest land,
And on the strangest sea;
Yet, never, in extremity,
It asked a crumb of me.
November 27, 2010
1st Sunday of Advent
This Sunday (Nov 28) is the first Sunday of Advent. The season of Advent marks the beginning of the Western (Roman Catholic, Anglican, and Protestant churches) Christian year. Advent begins four Sundays before Christmas and ends on Christmas Eve.
From the Latin adventus, Advent means “coming” or “arrival."
Throughout history this season has been observed as a fast, with its purpose focused on preparation for the coming Christ. During Advent, Christians all over the world prepare themselves to receive the newborn in a lowly manger, to celebrate the birth of Jesus the Messiah.
In this time, Christians also look forward to Jesus’ coming again and the establishment of God’s new creation.
Throughout Advent, Christians humbly confess their sin, seek God’s forgiveness, and joyfully look to Christ’s indwelling presence through the Holy Spirit. We wait and hope for Christ’s light to break through the darkness of our world. We wait and hope for the revelation of Christ with us, Christ among us.
But we are also called to do much more than simply wait and hope. God calls us to action. Throughout the season of Advent (and beyond), we are called to be Christ's light for salvation to the nations. We are led by God’s Spirit to enact God’s peace and justice in the world, as we put on the armor of light and seek to love. Who knows where this will lead us, or what trials will be encountered on the way. Anything can happen. But our call is remains the same: follow Christ, no matter what the cost.
As we embark on the Advent journey once again this year, consider these words from Romans 13:
Owe no one anything, except to love one another…Let us then cast off the works of darkness and put on the armor of light, let us conduct ourselves becomingly as in the day…clothe yourself with the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh, to gratify its desires.
From the Latin adventus, Advent means “coming” or “arrival."
Throughout history this season has been observed as a fast, with its purpose focused on preparation for the coming Christ. During Advent, Christians all over the world prepare themselves to receive the newborn in a lowly manger, to celebrate the birth of Jesus the Messiah.
In this time, Christians also look forward to Jesus’ coming again and the establishment of God’s new creation.
Throughout Advent, Christians humbly confess their sin, seek God’s forgiveness, and joyfully look to Christ’s indwelling presence through the Holy Spirit. We wait and hope for Christ’s light to break through the darkness of our world. We wait and hope for the revelation of Christ with us, Christ among us.
But we are also called to do much more than simply wait and hope. God calls us to action. Throughout the season of Advent (and beyond), we are called to be Christ's light for salvation to the nations. We are led by God’s Spirit to enact God’s peace and justice in the world, as we put on the armor of light and seek to love. Who knows where this will lead us, or what trials will be encountered on the way. Anything can happen. But our call is remains the same: follow Christ, no matter what the cost.
As we embark on the Advent journey once again this year, consider these words from Romans 13:
Owe no one anything, except to love one another…Let us then cast off the works of darkness and put on the armor of light, let us conduct ourselves becomingly as in the day…clothe yourself with the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh, to gratify its desires.
November 12, 2010
A Franciscan Benediction
May God bless you with discomfort
at easy answers, half-truths, and superficial relationships;
so that you may live deep within your heart.
May God bless you with anger
at injustice, oppression, and exploitation of people;
so that you may work for justice, freedom, and peace.
May God bless you with tears
to shed for those who suffer pain, rejection, hunger and war;
so that you may reach out your hand to comfort them and
to turn their pain into joy.
And may God bless you with enough foolishness
to believe that you can make a difference in the world;
so that you can do what others claim cannot be done:
to bring justice and kindness to all our children and the poor.
Amen
at easy answers, half-truths, and superficial relationships;
so that you may live deep within your heart.
May God bless you with anger
at injustice, oppression, and exploitation of people;
so that you may work for justice, freedom, and peace.
May God bless you with tears
to shed for those who suffer pain, rejection, hunger and war;
so that you may reach out your hand to comfort them and
to turn their pain into joy.
And may God bless you with enough foolishness
to believe that you can make a difference in the world;
so that you can do what others claim cannot be done:
to bring justice and kindness to all our children and the poor.
Amen
October 14, 2010
August 27, 2010
Where is the Church at Today?
To answer this question, we have to start at the beginning. 2000 years ago Jesus’ followers (people of “the Way”) made up a diverse, dynamic, persecuted, mission-oriented movement. These people of “the Way” were wounded healers, commissioned by God’s Spirit to bring new life wherever they went. Having received the powerful presence of the Holy Spirit, they became Christ’s “witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” (Acts 1.8). The entire book of Acts tells the story of the early churches quest to established small, localized Spirit-filled communities across the Roman Empire.
But it didn’t take long for the winds of change to sweep over the church. In about 300 years Jesus’ missionary church traveled from the dusty plains of Palestine to the royal quarts of the Roman Emperor, Constantine.
In a surprising twist of fate, almost in the blink of an eye, the church went from a dynamic, persecuted, mission-oriented movement to the state sponsored religion of the Roman Empire. Small, subversive enclaves gave way to state sponsored Cathedrals, elaborate liturgies, dense theologies, and massive, informal gatherings. Is this where it was meant to go? I guess on this side of heaven we’ll never truly know. But I have my doubts.
By the eleventh century the Church essentially controlled Western culture. And by the Middle Ages, the connection of church-and-state forged into an institutional interdependence between the pope and the ruler of the Holy Roman Empire. This Church-state partnership changed forever the social behaviors and religious practices of Europe. Many individuals and social structures were influenced and/or directed by the cultural force of Christendom. Members of society were assumed to be Christian via birth, baptism, confirmation, and participation in the Eucharist. And in some circles, the king or queen actually became the head of the church. This was the era of Christendom in Western civilization.
The cultural force of Christendom carried on through the Protestant Reformation and up to the period of the Enlightenment, at which point the winds of change started to blow again; this time, in a very different direction.
For the last 250 years the cultural force of Christendom has been in serious decline. The Church institution has lost much of its influence to shape society and cultural. And now, we live in what some people call a post-Christendom culture.
Yet, interestingly, much of the Western Church still envisions itself and its mission in terms of Christendom. In many respects, our institutions continue to act as though little has changed in 500 years. We still perceive ourselves as central to society and the surrounding culture. And we continue to follow an attractional, extractional model of Church that developed hundred’s of years ago. Assuming that people will flock to our sacred spaces, we still follow a “come-to-us” approach to outreach. And buildings remain central to our notion and experience of church.
Now please understand me, I’m not trying to put forward a simplistic anti-structure, anti-tradition, or anti-building sentiment. That would be far too easy. What I’m saying is that the Christendom model of Church is, in many respects, out of touch with where people are at today. For example, how can the Christendom model ever speak to the following people…
I was at a local coffee shop recently and there was a guy and girl who looked to be about 30, chatting it up right across from me. They were speaking loudly and it appeared they didn’t care if people could hear them. So, I decided to listen along while working on my computer!
As the guy reflected on his weekend he said “I was up with 8 of my buddies until 6:30 am on Saturday night [actually Sunday morning!], pouring drinks and watching the sun come up. It was awesome! But Sunday was pretty much a write off. I woke up at about 4 or 5 pm, and then a bunch of us went to a local pub to watch the team Canada hockey game” (this was during the 2010 Olympics).” He then joyfully commented, “The guys who own the pub are our age, which is really cool. They have pretty good food and they throw us some free beer’s all the time.” The guy’s phone then rings with a ring tone declaring: “Man on the run!”…he answers…“Hi, mom, how’s it going?” I could hardly contain my laughter!
The only “religion” language in their conversation was “I’m not a religious coffee drinker.” And quite apart from religion proper, they seemed to be very fond of the “late Saturday night” partying culture they’re immersed in. At the same time, they voiced their concern for issues related to social justice and they expressed their distain for our culture of gossip. Along with this I sensed in them a deep longing for community and solidarity.
So the question is: “How can the attractional, Christendom model of Church interact with such people? The problem is, it can’t when its main posture is to hope that people will “come to their senses” and “come to Church.” That’s not happening. I know it wasn’t happening for me during the first 18 years of my life; at least not until God met me in my social and work situation through a friend of mine. I didn’t know what the Church was and I didn’t care, at least not until one of God’s people met me in my world. And that gives me hope. But that hope is only realized when we live up to our God-given responsibility to connect with people where they’re at and to develop relationships of trust, in which the gospel can be heard.
If, however, we think most young people or young adults are going to walk off the street and into our Church buildings, we’re deceiving ourselves. We need new ways, new modes, new methods of being church in this post-Christendom culture. Figuring out how to get people to worship on Sunday is not the goal.
God is calling us to meet people in their space, to earn trust, to live holy lives, and to show people the new life that’s found in Jesus Christ. You might say God is calling us “to introduce Christianity into Christendom” (Soren Kierkegaard).
But it didn’t take long for the winds of change to sweep over the church. In about 300 years Jesus’ missionary church traveled from the dusty plains of Palestine to the royal quarts of the Roman Emperor, Constantine.
In a surprising twist of fate, almost in the blink of an eye, the church went from a dynamic, persecuted, mission-oriented movement to the state sponsored religion of the Roman Empire. Small, subversive enclaves gave way to state sponsored Cathedrals, elaborate liturgies, dense theologies, and massive, informal gatherings. Is this where it was meant to go? I guess on this side of heaven we’ll never truly know. But I have my doubts.
By the eleventh century the Church essentially controlled Western culture. And by the Middle Ages, the connection of church-and-state forged into an institutional interdependence between the pope and the ruler of the Holy Roman Empire. This Church-state partnership changed forever the social behaviors and religious practices of Europe. Many individuals and social structures were influenced and/or directed by the cultural force of Christendom. Members of society were assumed to be Christian via birth, baptism, confirmation, and participation in the Eucharist. And in some circles, the king or queen actually became the head of the church. This was the era of Christendom in Western civilization.
The cultural force of Christendom carried on through the Protestant Reformation and up to the period of the Enlightenment, at which point the winds of change started to blow again; this time, in a very different direction.
For the last 250 years the cultural force of Christendom has been in serious decline. The Church institution has lost much of its influence to shape society and cultural. And now, we live in what some people call a post-Christendom culture.
Yet, interestingly, much of the Western Church still envisions itself and its mission in terms of Christendom. In many respects, our institutions continue to act as though little has changed in 500 years. We still perceive ourselves as central to society and the surrounding culture. And we continue to follow an attractional, extractional model of Church that developed hundred’s of years ago. Assuming that people will flock to our sacred spaces, we still follow a “come-to-us” approach to outreach. And buildings remain central to our notion and experience of church.
Now please understand me, I’m not trying to put forward a simplistic anti-structure, anti-tradition, or anti-building sentiment. That would be far too easy. What I’m saying is that the Christendom model of Church is, in many respects, out of touch with where people are at today. For example, how can the Christendom model ever speak to the following people…
I was at a local coffee shop recently and there was a guy and girl who looked to be about 30, chatting it up right across from me. They were speaking loudly and it appeared they didn’t care if people could hear them. So, I decided to listen along while working on my computer!
As the guy reflected on his weekend he said “I was up with 8 of my buddies until 6:30 am on Saturday night [actually Sunday morning!], pouring drinks and watching the sun come up. It was awesome! But Sunday was pretty much a write off. I woke up at about 4 or 5 pm, and then a bunch of us went to a local pub to watch the team Canada hockey game” (this was during the 2010 Olympics).” He then joyfully commented, “The guys who own the pub are our age, which is really cool. They have pretty good food and they throw us some free beer’s all the time.” The guy’s phone then rings with a ring tone declaring: “Man on the run!”…he answers…“Hi, mom, how’s it going?” I could hardly contain my laughter!
The only “religion” language in their conversation was “I’m not a religious coffee drinker.” And quite apart from religion proper, they seemed to be very fond of the “late Saturday night” partying culture they’re immersed in. At the same time, they voiced their concern for issues related to social justice and they expressed their distain for our culture of gossip. Along with this I sensed in them a deep longing for community and solidarity.
So the question is: “How can the attractional, Christendom model of Church interact with such people? The problem is, it can’t when its main posture is to hope that people will “come to their senses” and “come to Church.” That’s not happening. I know it wasn’t happening for me during the first 18 years of my life; at least not until God met me in my social and work situation through a friend of mine. I didn’t know what the Church was and I didn’t care, at least not until one of God’s people met me in my world. And that gives me hope. But that hope is only realized when we live up to our God-given responsibility to connect with people where they’re at and to develop relationships of trust, in which the gospel can be heard.
If, however, we think most young people or young adults are going to walk off the street and into our Church buildings, we’re deceiving ourselves. We need new ways, new modes, new methods of being church in this post-Christendom culture. Figuring out how to get people to worship on Sunday is not the goal.
God is calling us to meet people in their space, to earn trust, to live holy lives, and to show people the new life that’s found in Jesus Christ. You might say God is calling us “to introduce Christianity into Christendom” (Soren Kierkegaard).
July 4, 2010
ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10, the Toronto G20, and the Protests in Toronto on June 26-27, 2010
Please, only read this post if you're willing to read it in its entirety. And I encourage you to read and/or watch the links throughout this paper (about 45 minutes). If you do not, it will be more challenging to understand my arguments and conclusions.
I am a person of peace and I am a follower of the Prince of Peace. I do not support violent acts or acts of vandalism. So let it be heard loud and clear that this reflection is NOT written in support of any violent acts committed on the streets of Toronto on June 26, 2010. People who burn police cars and vandalize people’s businesses should be stopped, arrested, and lawfully prosecuted. You heard that, right? OK. I also support appropriate and just policing. But I will not stand for the abuse of power and police brutality, for this stands in direct opposition to the Creator’s good intention for his creation.
That said, in this paper I will be reflecting on and critiquing three things: 1) the unpublished and unannounced passing of ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 made under The Ontario Public Works Protection Act for the Toronto G20; 2) the abuse of power and police brutality on the streets of Toronto on June 26-27, 2010; and 3) the detached, judgmental, and sometimes antagonistic perspective of some Canadians about what happened on the streets of Toronto on June 26-27, 2010.
I’ve read some people’s comments in the newspaper and on the Internet stating that anyone who went near Toronto’s downtown core on the weekend is an “idiot” or just plain “stupid.” They were looking for trouble and they found it, people seem to think. Some people are also saying that police/law enforcement officers were unquestionably in the right with all of their actions and uses of force, and that most of the protesters were in the wrong and deserved to get arrested. “Stay home and take a pill” is the kind of sentiment that some Canadians publicly communicated to concerned citizens and faithful protesters. This is also the tone of misinformed facebook comments/judgments I’ve read and radio talk shows I’ve heard. Such people ought to rethink the judgments they make (from a safe distance!) about other people and events that they themselves have no firsthand knowledge of.
I myself was not present in downtown Toronto last weekend, as I live in Halifax. But if I were in Toronto last week, I would have been marching in a lawful, peaceful protest. I do, however know a good friend, someone who is like family to me, who was a peaceful protester in downtown Toronto on Saturday. I trust my friend’s testimony completely. This person was mistreated and dehumanized by police and she was unlawfully thrown in jail for no reason. The personal story/testimony of my friend is the main reason why I am speaking publicly about the events that took place in Toronto on June 26-27, 2010. Through this paper, I stand in solidarity with my friend and with many other innocent people who were dehumanized and unlawfully arrested.
“The Ontario Public Works Protection Act”
The Ontario Public Works Protection Act was established in 1939 to protect courthouses, police stations, and public utilities, and to prevent the assassination of public figures. This Protection Act allows “guards” (ie. police officers/peace officers) the authority to define what “public property” is. A “public work includes any provincial and any municipal public building, and any other building, place or work designated a public work by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.” Basically, a public work can be any amount of space and it can’t be opposed in court. Under this Act, all “guards” are “in charge of the protecting of the public work.”
Powers of guard or peace officer:
A guard or peace officer,
(a) may require any person entering or attempting to enter any public work or any approach thereto to furnish his or her name and address, to identify himself or herself and to state the purpose for which he or she desires to enter the public work, in writing or otherwise;
(b) may search, without warrant, any person entering or attempting to enter a public work or a vehicle in the charge or under the control of any such person or which has recently been or is suspected of having been in the charge or under the control of any such person or in which any such person is a passenger; and
(c) may refuse permission to any person to enter a public work and use such force as is necessary to prevent any such person from so entering.
Arrest:
A guard or peace officer may arrest, without warrant, any person who neglects or refuses to comply with a request or direction of a guard or peace officer, or who is found upon or attempting to enter a public work without lawful authority.
Why am I saying all of this, you may ask?
Reason: A few weeks before the Toronto G20, the Toronto Chief of Police asked the Ontario Cabinet to pass ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10, which was made under The Ontario Public Works Protection Act for the Toronto G20.
This unpublished and unannounced regulation was quietly passed on June 2. This unprecedented regulation (that empowered police to arrest anyone near the G20 “security zone” who refuses to identify themselves or agree to a police search) kicked in on June 18 and expired on June 28. In a June 25, 2010 column in the Toronto Star, Jennifer Yang notes: “While the new regulation appeared without notice on the province’s e-Laws online database last week, it won’t be officially published in The Ontario Gazette until July 3 — one week after the regulation expires.”
The Ontario Cabinet did NOT publicly disclose its intent to pass ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10, which should have been published for public comment before it passed. This was a very undemocratic decision on the part of the Ontario Cabinet.
PLEASE watch this IMPORTANT interview with Paul Cavalluzzo, which details some implications of passing ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 made under The Ontario Public Works Act: Jay interviews Cavalluzzo
In an interview with The Real News, Toronto Mayor David Miller says, “the one thing that should have been handled differently is that these regulations, like any normal regulation, should have been published for public comment. People can make all the comments they are making now, ahead of time. That’s the way regulations are supposed to be done in this country. That’s what democracy is all about. They should be posted, people can comment on them and their appropriateness for or against…The Ontario Cabinet chose to do this, and I think what should be challenged there is the fact the Ontario Cabinet should have made sure it was done publicly. The Premier should have done that and they should have made sure that, as it has to do with most regulations, that people have the opportunity to comment before it gets passed. That’s the flaw.”
What the mayor says here is true, to a certain extent. The regulation being "published for public comment" is not the one and only thing that should have been "handled differently." There is so much more to this situation.
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association is saying that it was “unconstitutional” for the police to use this legislation to broaden their powers to search and demand identification from any citizen far beyond the allotted “five meters” of the G20 security fence.
More specifically, one could argue that the legislation and regulation in question violate sections 7-10 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and are not defensible as reasonable limits on those rights per section 1 of the Charter. A lawyer friend recently said to me, "I can't help but wonder whether the authorities were indifferent to that possibility, calculating cynically that the violation could be declared by a court only well after the protests had been suppressed. The possibility that this is the case is deeply disturbing."
ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 was used to “guard” the G20 and it was applied to the “security fence.” But law enforcement could extend the “security fence” WITHOUT ANYONE HAVING APPROPRIATE NOTIFICATION AHEAD OF TIME. If anyone resisted identifying themselves, or agreeing to a police search, police could use excessive force with them! No questions asked! So, for thousands of uninformed citizen on the streets of Toronto, this excessive use of police force was impossible to understand. The result of which was an unnecessary escalation of conflict and violence, which, in turn, unnecessarily put the general public at risk.
Paul Jay, of The Real News, says this legislation essentially established “martial law in the area around the G20, suspending probable cause, and giving rights of search and seizure to all law enforcement officers.” Police (who were dressed in riot gear) gave uninformed people a few seconds to get out of free speech zones, and when people did not move, the police deemed their assembly to be illegal, and police moved in on people with a severe amount of force. Again, my good friend has given me eyewitness testimony of this police activity.
Two obvious problems are on the table at this point: 1) Why was ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 passed by the Ontario Cabinet, and how did this happen without it being published for public comment, or without anyone raising the question of it violating sections 7-10 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms? 2) Because of the first problem, the people who gathered for lawful protest during the Toronto G20 did not know what was going on BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT PROPERLY INFORMED. And they were therefore unnecessarily put in danger’s way when police began to forcefully remove them from designated areas of protest. The result is that police indiscriminately arrested upwards of 900 people!
All Canadians must be informed of drastic alterations to the law and unprecedented authority being granted to law enforcement BEFORE our normal laws are suspended and new laws are put in place by the authorities. But Canadian citizens were NOT informed and we were NOT allowed to comment on or debate the validity of ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 made under The Ontario Public Works Protection Act.
All of this left many peaceful protesters in a very vulnerable situation in downtown Toronto on the weekend of June 26-27, 2010. The people who were LAWFULLY AND PEACEFULLY protesting in Queen’s Park (and elsewhere) had no idea that the police could, at any moment, aggressively box them in and arrest them for not moving or for refusing to identify themselves. Thousands of people were confused and disoriented because of this, and they were needlessly put in a very vulnerable and dangerous situation.
This entire scenario is nothing less than a cruel, manipulative violation and subversion of the civil liberties of Canadian citizens. It resulted in NO freedom of speech and NO right to assemble for many people. (I will further substantiate this claim in the next section of this paper.) Even for many journalists, the message from law enforcement was: You can stay in this area, but if you do, you will be arrested! Do we not realize the implications of such a message from so-called law enforcement? At a public event such as this one, we need journalists to be on sight and reporting the news.
The Events of June 26, 2010
On Saturday, June 26, a good friend of mine walked in lawful and peaceful protests, chanting peace slogans along the way. But when she ended up in the Queen and Spadina area, she witnessed a very disturbing chain of events. She saw angry people burning a police car and vandalizing storefronts. My friend told me that over 100 police officers dressed in riot gear stood by and did nothing to prevent this from happening, nor did they do anything to prevent the situation from escalating. From my friend’s perspective, the police stood by and allowed around 100 people to perform disturbing acts of vandalism on Queen Street.
It is reported that these vandals were then allowed to walk away and damage more public property on their way back to Queen’s Park, without police presence or interference. At Queen’s Park, the vandals then freely removed their black clothing and reintegrate into the masses of peaceful protesters.
Please watch this video by photojournalist Joe Wenkoff that documents this chain of events: Joe Wenkoff
This was a very curious, suspicious, and disturbing “non-action” on the part of police, who, it seems, could have done a lot to keep the pubic safe and to prevent major damage being done in the city. It is hard to believe the police could do nothing when people torched police cars and smashed windows on three of Toronto’s busiest streets (Queen, Younge, and Bay). I guess 1 billion dollars of federal spending for security at the G8 and G20 was not enough to prevent this from happening!
When my friend was back at Queen’s Park in the designated protest area later in the afternoon on Saturday, she experienced something she will never forget. She witnessed outright police brutality, when police began to march through Queen’s Park. Police kicked innocent and unarmed people in the face, pepper sprayed people, beat men and women on the shins and hands with police batons, and pushed 50-60 year old women. While people were gathered in a designated protest zone, they were completely taken off guard by this brutal show of police force.
Police also strategically boxed in many peaceful protesters with little or no warning and gave them no instructions as to how they could avoid getting hemmed in. According to my friend, the police totally ignored her when she asked what to do, or how to escape the blockade.
Police also jumped and arrested individuals as the police line moved through Queens Park. To be fair, some of the people who were jumped and arrested were probably vandals who reintegrated into the larger crowds. But the question still remains: Why didn’t the police move in and make these arrests when the vandals were dressed in black and were committing crimes in plain sight?
My friend is NOT an idiot because she was in downtown Toronto to witness these events. She is a concerned, responsible Canadian citizen and a peace-loving Christian. She was simply exercising her democratic right to free speech on Saturday, while she marched in lawful protests and while she spent time in designated protest areas.
YET, she and about 30 other people who were walking down a sidewalk late in the afternoon on Saturday, were chased down by police on bikes, then cornered by police on foot, and unlawfully arrested. These people did not provoke the police, yet they were falsely accused, humiliated, openly searched, and unnecessarily arrested by police. My friend did nothing to provoke the authorities. Nor did she deserve to be arrested.
The only justification given by the police officer in charge was that these people looked to him “like they had not worked a day in their lives.” Therefore, they “deserved to spend a night in jail.” This so-called “Toronto G20 Detention Centre” was made up of dozens of small cages, like the ones we store animals in. See: G20 Detention Centre
My friend was stuffed like a sardine (along with 25-30 other people, which was over the 10-20 person limit) into a “cage.” People could hardly move. In her cage, my friend remained in handcuffs and was not allowed to be uncuffed so she could use the door-less bathroom. In fact, women had to help wipe each other’s behinds while on the toilet because they were handcuffed.
Furthermore, my friend was unlawfully DENIED HER RIGHT TO COUNCIL. She was unlawfully denied her right to speak to a lawyer and her right to make a phone call. Even hardened criminals are not denied those rights in Canada. To top it off, all the people in her “cage” were DENIED ACCESS TO DRINKING WATER FOR 6 HOURS, water they were begging for.
When my friend was released on Sunday, it took police 5 minutes to complete her paper work and she was not charged because THERE WAS NO CHARGE AGAINST HER! She was simply perceived by police as a dirty protester. The authorities shut her up. And the authorities' aggressive and undemocratic message to her (and to thousands of others) was simple: Get the hell out of Toronto because you are not welcome here!
Most everything I have just shared about my friend’s story has DEHUMANIZATION AND INJUSTICE written all over it. This makes me sick to my stomach, and at this point, it makes me feel ashamed to be Canadian!
So, for those Canadians who are writing ignorant or destructive comments on the Internet, who are talking smack over the airwaves, and who are blindly supporting gross abuses of authority and police brutality, my message for you is simple:
Wake up! Don’t be numb and apathetic. Open your eyes to see injustice and clean out your ears so you can hear about injustice when it’s right in front of you. Seek the truth honestly and follow the right path no matter where it leads you.
It deeply concerns me when Canadian citizens are willing to condemn thousands of peaceful protesters, who gather outside the G20 to exercise their democratic right to speak in peaceful protest about a variety of issues. When people (including women and journalists) are BEAT UP, MISTREATED, AND ARRESTED BY POLICE, how can people uncritically defend those same police officers and the officials in charge of them?
But if you still think there was no abuse of authority, or police brutality in Toronto on June 26-27, please, I’m begging you, converse with people who were in Toronto and experienced it for themselves! Please, take time to do that!
If that is impossible, you can watch lots of video and eyewitness accounts that will reveal what you need to know. For example:
Steve Paikin, veteran Canadian journalist, talks about peaceful protesting on Saturday, a police attack against peaceful protest, and describes the arrest and beating of a Guardian newspaper journalist: Steve Paikin
Journalist, Jesse Freeston is interviewed on CTV: Freeston
Scott Harris, Council of Canadians, on Canada AM: Harris
Cassandra J., witness and subject of police action: Cassandra
Geoffrey B., witness and subject of police action: Geoffrey
Adam B., witness and subject of police action: Adam
Clarence B., witness and subject of police action: Clarence
Public Inquiry on the Toronto G20
For a commentary on growing demands for a public inquiry on the Toronto G20, go to: The Council for Canadians
I invite any rebuttals, comments, or corrections to what I have written in this paper. I hope and pray the conversation will move forward in a ruthlessly honest, yet loving and compassionate manner.
In hope for a more just Canada,
Brad Close
I am a person of peace and I am a follower of the Prince of Peace. I do not support violent acts or acts of vandalism. So let it be heard loud and clear that this reflection is NOT written in support of any violent acts committed on the streets of Toronto on June 26, 2010. People who burn police cars and vandalize people’s businesses should be stopped, arrested, and lawfully prosecuted. You heard that, right? OK. I also support appropriate and just policing. But I will not stand for the abuse of power and police brutality, for this stands in direct opposition to the Creator’s good intention for his creation.
That said, in this paper I will be reflecting on and critiquing three things: 1) the unpublished and unannounced passing of ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 made under The Ontario Public Works Protection Act for the Toronto G20; 2) the abuse of power and police brutality on the streets of Toronto on June 26-27, 2010; and 3) the detached, judgmental, and sometimes antagonistic perspective of some Canadians about what happened on the streets of Toronto on June 26-27, 2010.
I’ve read some people’s comments in the newspaper and on the Internet stating that anyone who went near Toronto’s downtown core on the weekend is an “idiot” or just plain “stupid.” They were looking for trouble and they found it, people seem to think. Some people are also saying that police/law enforcement officers were unquestionably in the right with all of their actions and uses of force, and that most of the protesters were in the wrong and deserved to get arrested. “Stay home and take a pill” is the kind of sentiment that some Canadians publicly communicated to concerned citizens and faithful protesters. This is also the tone of misinformed facebook comments/judgments I’ve read and radio talk shows I’ve heard. Such people ought to rethink the judgments they make (from a safe distance!) about other people and events that they themselves have no firsthand knowledge of.
I myself was not present in downtown Toronto last weekend, as I live in Halifax. But if I were in Toronto last week, I would have been marching in a lawful, peaceful protest. I do, however know a good friend, someone who is like family to me, who was a peaceful protester in downtown Toronto on Saturday. I trust my friend’s testimony completely. This person was mistreated and dehumanized by police and she was unlawfully thrown in jail for no reason. The personal story/testimony of my friend is the main reason why I am speaking publicly about the events that took place in Toronto on June 26-27, 2010. Through this paper, I stand in solidarity with my friend and with many other innocent people who were dehumanized and unlawfully arrested.
“The Ontario Public Works Protection Act”
The Ontario Public Works Protection Act was established in 1939 to protect courthouses, police stations, and public utilities, and to prevent the assassination of public figures. This Protection Act allows “guards” (ie. police officers/peace officers) the authority to define what “public property” is. A “public work includes any provincial and any municipal public building, and any other building, place or work designated a public work by the Lieutenant Governor in Council.” Basically, a public work can be any amount of space and it can’t be opposed in court. Under this Act, all “guards” are “in charge of the protecting of the public work.”
Powers of guard or peace officer:
A guard or peace officer,
(a) may require any person entering or attempting to enter any public work or any approach thereto to furnish his or her name and address, to identify himself or herself and to state the purpose for which he or she desires to enter the public work, in writing or otherwise;
(b) may search, without warrant, any person entering or attempting to enter a public work or a vehicle in the charge or under the control of any such person or which has recently been or is suspected of having been in the charge or under the control of any such person or in which any such person is a passenger; and
(c) may refuse permission to any person to enter a public work and use such force as is necessary to prevent any such person from so entering.
Arrest:
A guard or peace officer may arrest, without warrant, any person who neglects or refuses to comply with a request or direction of a guard or peace officer, or who is found upon or attempting to enter a public work without lawful authority.
Why am I saying all of this, you may ask?
Reason: A few weeks before the Toronto G20, the Toronto Chief of Police asked the Ontario Cabinet to pass ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10, which was made under The Ontario Public Works Protection Act for the Toronto G20.
This unpublished and unannounced regulation was quietly passed on June 2. This unprecedented regulation (that empowered police to arrest anyone near the G20 “security zone” who refuses to identify themselves or agree to a police search) kicked in on June 18 and expired on June 28. In a June 25, 2010 column in the Toronto Star, Jennifer Yang notes: “While the new regulation appeared without notice on the province’s e-Laws online database last week, it won’t be officially published in The Ontario Gazette until July 3 — one week after the regulation expires.”
The Ontario Cabinet did NOT publicly disclose its intent to pass ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10, which should have been published for public comment before it passed. This was a very undemocratic decision on the part of the Ontario Cabinet.
PLEASE watch this IMPORTANT interview with Paul Cavalluzzo, which details some implications of passing ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 made under The Ontario Public Works Act: Jay interviews Cavalluzzo
In an interview with The Real News, Toronto Mayor David Miller says, “the one thing that should have been handled differently is that these regulations, like any normal regulation, should have been published for public comment. People can make all the comments they are making now, ahead of time. That’s the way regulations are supposed to be done in this country. That’s what democracy is all about. They should be posted, people can comment on them and their appropriateness for or against…The Ontario Cabinet chose to do this, and I think what should be challenged there is the fact the Ontario Cabinet should have made sure it was done publicly. The Premier should have done that and they should have made sure that, as it has to do with most regulations, that people have the opportunity to comment before it gets passed. That’s the flaw.”
What the mayor says here is true, to a certain extent. The regulation being "published for public comment" is not the one and only thing that should have been "handled differently." There is so much more to this situation.
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association is saying that it was “unconstitutional” for the police to use this legislation to broaden their powers to search and demand identification from any citizen far beyond the allotted “five meters” of the G20 security fence.
More specifically, one could argue that the legislation and regulation in question violate sections 7-10 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and are not defensible as reasonable limits on those rights per section 1 of the Charter. A lawyer friend recently said to me, "I can't help but wonder whether the authorities were indifferent to that possibility, calculating cynically that the violation could be declared by a court only well after the protests had been suppressed. The possibility that this is the case is deeply disturbing."
ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 was used to “guard” the G20 and it was applied to the “security fence.” But law enforcement could extend the “security fence” WITHOUT ANYONE HAVING APPROPRIATE NOTIFICATION AHEAD OF TIME. If anyone resisted identifying themselves, or agreeing to a police search, police could use excessive force with them! No questions asked! So, for thousands of uninformed citizen on the streets of Toronto, this excessive use of police force was impossible to understand. The result of which was an unnecessary escalation of conflict and violence, which, in turn, unnecessarily put the general public at risk.
Paul Jay, of The Real News, says this legislation essentially established “martial law in the area around the G20, suspending probable cause, and giving rights of search and seizure to all law enforcement officers.” Police (who were dressed in riot gear) gave uninformed people a few seconds to get out of free speech zones, and when people did not move, the police deemed their assembly to be illegal, and police moved in on people with a severe amount of force. Again, my good friend has given me eyewitness testimony of this police activity.
Two obvious problems are on the table at this point: 1) Why was ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 passed by the Ontario Cabinet, and how did this happen without it being published for public comment, or without anyone raising the question of it violating sections 7-10 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms? 2) Because of the first problem, the people who gathered for lawful protest during the Toronto G20 did not know what was going on BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT PROPERLY INFORMED. And they were therefore unnecessarily put in danger’s way when police began to forcefully remove them from designated areas of protest. The result is that police indiscriminately arrested upwards of 900 people!
All Canadians must be informed of drastic alterations to the law and unprecedented authority being granted to law enforcement BEFORE our normal laws are suspended and new laws are put in place by the authorities. But Canadian citizens were NOT informed and we were NOT allowed to comment on or debate the validity of ONTARIO REGULATION 233/10 made under The Ontario Public Works Protection Act.
All of this left many peaceful protesters in a very vulnerable situation in downtown Toronto on the weekend of June 26-27, 2010. The people who were LAWFULLY AND PEACEFULLY protesting in Queen’s Park (and elsewhere) had no idea that the police could, at any moment, aggressively box them in and arrest them for not moving or for refusing to identify themselves. Thousands of people were confused and disoriented because of this, and they were needlessly put in a very vulnerable and dangerous situation.
This entire scenario is nothing less than a cruel, manipulative violation and subversion of the civil liberties of Canadian citizens. It resulted in NO freedom of speech and NO right to assemble for many people. (I will further substantiate this claim in the next section of this paper.) Even for many journalists, the message from law enforcement was: You can stay in this area, but if you do, you will be arrested! Do we not realize the implications of such a message from so-called law enforcement? At a public event such as this one, we need journalists to be on sight and reporting the news.
The Events of June 26, 2010
On Saturday, June 26, a good friend of mine walked in lawful and peaceful protests, chanting peace slogans along the way. But when she ended up in the Queen and Spadina area, she witnessed a very disturbing chain of events. She saw angry people burning a police car and vandalizing storefronts. My friend told me that over 100 police officers dressed in riot gear stood by and did nothing to prevent this from happening, nor did they do anything to prevent the situation from escalating. From my friend’s perspective, the police stood by and allowed around 100 people to perform disturbing acts of vandalism on Queen Street.
It is reported that these vandals were then allowed to walk away and damage more public property on their way back to Queen’s Park, without police presence or interference. At Queen’s Park, the vandals then freely removed their black clothing and reintegrate into the masses of peaceful protesters.
Please watch this video by photojournalist Joe Wenkoff that documents this chain of events: Joe Wenkoff
This was a very curious, suspicious, and disturbing “non-action” on the part of police, who, it seems, could have done a lot to keep the pubic safe and to prevent major damage being done in the city. It is hard to believe the police could do nothing when people torched police cars and smashed windows on three of Toronto’s busiest streets (Queen, Younge, and Bay). I guess 1 billion dollars of federal spending for security at the G8 and G20 was not enough to prevent this from happening!
When my friend was back at Queen’s Park in the designated protest area later in the afternoon on Saturday, she experienced something she will never forget. She witnessed outright police brutality, when police began to march through Queen’s Park. Police kicked innocent and unarmed people in the face, pepper sprayed people, beat men and women on the shins and hands with police batons, and pushed 50-60 year old women. While people were gathered in a designated protest zone, they were completely taken off guard by this brutal show of police force.
Police also strategically boxed in many peaceful protesters with little or no warning and gave them no instructions as to how they could avoid getting hemmed in. According to my friend, the police totally ignored her when she asked what to do, or how to escape the blockade.
Police also jumped and arrested individuals as the police line moved through Queens Park. To be fair, some of the people who were jumped and arrested were probably vandals who reintegrated into the larger crowds. But the question still remains: Why didn’t the police move in and make these arrests when the vandals were dressed in black and were committing crimes in plain sight?
My friend is NOT an idiot because she was in downtown Toronto to witness these events. She is a concerned, responsible Canadian citizen and a peace-loving Christian. She was simply exercising her democratic right to free speech on Saturday, while she marched in lawful protests and while she spent time in designated protest areas.
YET, she and about 30 other people who were walking down a sidewalk late in the afternoon on Saturday, were chased down by police on bikes, then cornered by police on foot, and unlawfully arrested. These people did not provoke the police, yet they were falsely accused, humiliated, openly searched, and unnecessarily arrested by police. My friend did nothing to provoke the authorities. Nor did she deserve to be arrested.
The only justification given by the police officer in charge was that these people looked to him “like they had not worked a day in their lives.” Therefore, they “deserved to spend a night in jail.” This so-called “Toronto G20 Detention Centre” was made up of dozens of small cages, like the ones we store animals in. See: G20 Detention Centre
My friend was stuffed like a sardine (along with 25-30 other people, which was over the 10-20 person limit) into a “cage.” People could hardly move. In her cage, my friend remained in handcuffs and was not allowed to be uncuffed so she could use the door-less bathroom. In fact, women had to help wipe each other’s behinds while on the toilet because they were handcuffed.
Furthermore, my friend was unlawfully DENIED HER RIGHT TO COUNCIL. She was unlawfully denied her right to speak to a lawyer and her right to make a phone call. Even hardened criminals are not denied those rights in Canada. To top it off, all the people in her “cage” were DENIED ACCESS TO DRINKING WATER FOR 6 HOURS, water they were begging for.
When my friend was released on Sunday, it took police 5 minutes to complete her paper work and she was not charged because THERE WAS NO CHARGE AGAINST HER! She was simply perceived by police as a dirty protester. The authorities shut her up. And the authorities' aggressive and undemocratic message to her (and to thousands of others) was simple: Get the hell out of Toronto because you are not welcome here!
Most everything I have just shared about my friend’s story has DEHUMANIZATION AND INJUSTICE written all over it. This makes me sick to my stomach, and at this point, it makes me feel ashamed to be Canadian!
So, for those Canadians who are writing ignorant or destructive comments on the Internet, who are talking smack over the airwaves, and who are blindly supporting gross abuses of authority and police brutality, my message for you is simple:
Wake up! Don’t be numb and apathetic. Open your eyes to see injustice and clean out your ears so you can hear about injustice when it’s right in front of you. Seek the truth honestly and follow the right path no matter where it leads you.
It deeply concerns me when Canadian citizens are willing to condemn thousands of peaceful protesters, who gather outside the G20 to exercise their democratic right to speak in peaceful protest about a variety of issues. When people (including women and journalists) are BEAT UP, MISTREATED, AND ARRESTED BY POLICE, how can people uncritically defend those same police officers and the officials in charge of them?
But if you still think there was no abuse of authority, or police brutality in Toronto on June 26-27, please, I’m begging you, converse with people who were in Toronto and experienced it for themselves! Please, take time to do that!
If that is impossible, you can watch lots of video and eyewitness accounts that will reveal what you need to know. For example:
Steve Paikin, veteran Canadian journalist, talks about peaceful protesting on Saturday, a police attack against peaceful protest, and describes the arrest and beating of a Guardian newspaper journalist: Steve Paikin
Journalist, Jesse Freeston is interviewed on CTV: Freeston
Scott Harris, Council of Canadians, on Canada AM: Harris
Cassandra J., witness and subject of police action: Cassandra
Geoffrey B., witness and subject of police action: Geoffrey
Adam B., witness and subject of police action: Adam
Clarence B., witness and subject of police action: Clarence
Public Inquiry on the Toronto G20
For a commentary on growing demands for a public inquiry on the Toronto G20, go to: The Council for Canadians
I invite any rebuttals, comments, or corrections to what I have written in this paper. I hope and pray the conversation will move forward in a ruthlessly honest, yet loving and compassionate manner.
In hope for a more just Canada,
Brad Close
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)